Study

Reading Together

For two or three who wish to study together: an order of meeting, a few rules of speech taken from the desert, and twelve sessions of readings and questions.

"They shall eat in common, bless in common, and take counsel in common."

After the Community Rule

The fellowship began with five readers at a borrowed table, and nearly everything we know we learned by reading aloud to one another and then arguing gently about it. The desert community would have thought it strange to study any other way. Their Rule requires that the many keep watch together for a third of every night of the year, to read the book, to study, and to bless together, and that wherever ten of them are found, one shall always be at the Law.

Most students of this site read alone, and the Questions and Answers page has said that this is enough. But if you can find one other person, or two, the way opens differently. This page is a guide for such a company. It asks for an hour, a table, and no leader. It works as well by telephone or by letter as in a room. A student who has no one may use the questions with a notebook, one session a week, and will find further down a word for her.

An Order of Meeting

We suggest the same order every time. A fixed order frees the mind for the reading, and it lets a shy person know what will be asked of her.

  • Silence. Two minutes, to arrive. Phones away. The Essenes spoke of nothing worldly before the dawn prayers; two minutes is a small dawn.
  • A Lection. One person reads one of the Lections aloud, or a psalm.
  • The reading. The page for the session, or the passage from an ancient text, is read aloud, slowly, taking turns by paragraphs. It should already have been read once at home. Hearing it is different.
  • The round. Each person in turn reads out the one sentence that stopped her, without explaining why. No one comments. This is the heart of the meeting, and it takes five minutes.
  • The questions. Take the questions for the session one at a time. Not everyone need answer every question. Twenty or thirty minutes.
  • One thing to keep. Each person names one small practice she will keep until the next meeting, small enough to be certain of doing.
  • The close. A minute of silence, and then each says one thing she is thankful for. If there is food, it is blessed and shared now, and it should be plain: bread, fruit, water.

Rules of Speech

The Community Rule is exact about how the members spoke in session, and the fellowship has found its rules better than any modern ones. We have kept the rules and left out the penalties.

  • Speak in turn. In the Rule each spoke in the order of his rank. A company of friends has no ranks, so go around the table, and begin with a different person each time.
  • Do not interrupt. No one, says the Rule, shall speak in the middle of his fellow's words, before his brother has finished. The ancients fined a man ten days for it. Simply wait.
  • No one speaks twice until all have spoken once.
  • Do not mend one another. A person who says what troubled her in the reading has not asked for advice. Thank her and go on.
  • Ask for the page. If someone says the Essenes did this or that, anyone may ask, kindly, where it is written. This is the second question of the Discernment room, and it keeps a study circle from becoming a rumor.
  • What is said at the table stays at the table.
  • Take turns. One person reads the Lection, another keeps the time, another chooses the bread. Change every meeting. The keepers of the fellowship take turns at everything, as the About page says, and no one among us has ever been in charge.

Twelve Sessions

The sessions below make a course of three months if you meet weekly, or a year if you meet monthly. Each names what to read and gives three questions. The first question in each is about the text, the second about the people who wrote it, and the third about you.

One: Who They Were

Read The Essenes in History and The Three Witnesses.

  • On what do the three witnesses agree, and why does the fellowship trust those points most?
  • Each witness admired the Essenes from outside and had his own reasons. What did each want his readers to see?
  • If three strangers described your household from outside, what would they get right, and what would they miss?

Two: Why They Went

Read Before the Desert and The Desert as Teacher.

  • What had gone wrong in Jerusalem, in the eyes of those who left?
  • Could they have done what they did in a kinder place than the shore of the Dead Sea? What did the harshness give them?
  • The movement began with twenty years of groping for the way. Have you had such years? Are you in them now?

Three: The Common Life

Read The Community Rule.

  • The Rule asks a member to bring knowledge, powers, and possessions, in that order. Why is knowledge first?
  • Nearly all the small penalties protect one person's attention from another. What does that say about what they valued?
  • Which of the three do you find hardest to share: what you know, what you can do, or what you have?

Four: The Two Spirits

Read Children of Light.

  • The Rule says that the children of light also go astray. Why does the fellowship call this the sentence that makes the whole teaching?
  • The community divided humanity into two lots. Where is that division a help to a person, and where does it become a danger?
  • Read the two lists of marks aloud. Which single word in each list was yours this week?

Five: Water

Read The Washing in Living Water, The Voice in the Wilderness, and Locusts and Wild Honey.

  • The Rule says that no water cleanses a person who has not turned. What, then, is the washing for?
  • How did John's washing differ from the community's, and what might the difference have cost him?
  • What discipline have you kept from a house you have left?

Six: The Table

Read The Table of the Messiah and The Shape of the House.

  • Who was barred from the meal of the last days, and what reason does the scroll give?
  • The community built its house like the temple, room within room. What were they protecting?
  • Walk your own house as the page suggests. Is it all door, or all wall? Who has not eaten at your table who might?

Seven: The Ones to Come

Read Two Anointed Ones and He Will Make the Dead Live.

  • Why did the community look for a priest and a king, and not one figure who was both?
  • A fragment from the caves and a saying of Jesus list the same works of the last days in nearly the same order. What might that tell us about what John, in prison, was listening for?
  • In your own life, which goes first: the one who blesses, or the one who decides?

Eight: Fate and Choice

Read The One Law and If All Is Appointed.

  • How could a people who believed that everything is appointed also be the strictest people in Israel about what each member chose to do?
  • The hymns give God the credit for every good thing in the singer and take the blame for every bad one. Is that inconsistent? Is it wise?
  • Where do you use the thought that it was meant to be as rest, and where as an excuse?

Nine: The Walk

Read A Path Worn by Walking and The Way of Practice.

  • What does it change to hear the word way as a road under the feet and not as a method?
  • Both the desert community and the first followers of Jesus called themselves the Way. What did each mean by it?
  • Where did your feet actually go this week? Trace it. What does the track say?

Ten: The War

Read The War Scroll and The Fourth Philosophy.

  • The scroll gives the darkness three victories out of seven. Why would a community write that about itself?
  • The members renounced revenge and stored their anger for a later day. What became of the stored anger when the legions came?
  • What are you storing?

Eleven: The Test

Read Was Jesus an Essene? and Discipline Is Not Merit.

  • The article says that where Jesus stands closest to the Essenes he most often turns them around. Which reversal strikes you most?
  • The strictest rule in Israel ends with a hymn confessing that the rule does not save. What do you make of that?
  • Where, lately, has your discipline kept a sheep in the pit?

Twelve: What Remains

Read After Jerusalem and The Finding of the Scrolls.

  • Of the four things that may have become of the Essenes, which does the fellowship hold dearest, and why?
  • Someone wrapped a scroll in linen and put it in a jar with an army on the road. What did that person believe?
  • What would you put in a jar for those who come after you, and have you written it down?

If You Read Alone

Use the same sessions with a notebook. Read the page aloud to the room; the people of the scrolls rarely read silently, and neither should you. Write down the sentence that stopped you. Write your answer to the third question only, in a few lines, and date it. The first two questions will answer themselves as you write.

At the end of twelve weeks read the notebook through. You will have, in your own hand, the beginnings of a rule of life, and you will have kept company with yourself more honestly than most people ever do. The article Attention Is Not Belonging has more to say to the student who reads alone and wishes she did not.

When a Circle Goes Wrong

Three things spoil a reading circle, and the fellowship has done all of them.

One person does the talking. The rule that no one speaks twice until all have spoken once is the cure, and whoever keeps the time should feel free to invoke it with a smile.

The reading turns into a debate. A circle exists to hear the text and one another, not to settle the date of the Teacher of Righteousness. When an argument starts, someone should ask for the page, and if there is no page, the company should go on to the next question.

The meeting replaces the practice. It is pleasant to talk about the Morning Watch and much harder to keep it. A circle whose members talk every week and rise before the sun on none of the days between has become, in the words of the Lection, a company carrying water in a basket. This is why every meeting ends with one thing to keep, and why the next meeting might well begin by asking, without reproach, whether it was kept.

The desert community had an overseer to guard against these things. You have each other, which is harder and better. Begin with one other person and one page. The Begin Here page will tell you both what to do in the mornings between.