Of the seven scrolls that came out of the first cave, one was a rule. It is written in a clear hand on five sheets of leather sewn end to end, eleven columns in all, and it was copied about a hundred years before the birth of Jesus. Fragments of ten or more further copies were found in other caves. No other text takes us so far inside the life of the desert community, and the fellowship asks every student to read it through at least once in a good translation. The page on The Dead Sea Scrolls gives it a paragraph. This page walks through it from beginning to end, so that the student knows what she is looking at when she opens it.
The Purpose
The Rule opens by saying what the community is for: to seek God with a whole heart and soul, to do what is good and right before him as he commanded through Moses and all his servants the prophets, to love all that he has chosen and hate all that he has rejected, to keep far from all evil and hold fast to every good deed.
Then comes a sentence the fellowship has thought about for many years. All who freely devote themselves to his truth shall bring all their knowledge, their powers, and their possessions into the community of God, that they may purify their knowledge in the truth of his statutes, order their powers according to his perfect ways, and all their possessions according to his righteous counsel. The witnesses noticed the possessions. The Rule puts knowledge first. What a member knew and what a member could do were handed in along with his purse, and were handed in to be purified, not merely pooled.
The Covenant Ceremony
The Rule then describes how the covenant is entered, in a ceremony repeated every year for as long as the dominion of Belial lasts. The priests recite the mighty deeds of God and his mercies to Israel. The Levites recite the sins of Israel under that dominion. Those entering answer with a confession: we have strayed, we have disobeyed, we and our fathers before us. The priests bless all the men of God's lot in words that open out the old priestly blessing: may he bless you with every good and keep you from every evil, may he enlighten your heart with the wisdom of life and favor you with eternal knowledge, may he lift his gracious face toward you for everlasting peace. The Levites curse the men of the lot of Belial. And after each, all the people say: amen, amen.
They pass in order, the priests first, then the Levites, then all the people one after another in their thousands and hundreds and fifties and tens, so that every man of Israel may know his place in the community of God. No one is to move down from his place or up from it.
The passage ends with a warning for the man who enters while keeping the stubbornness of his heart. He shall not be made clean by atonement, nor purified by waters of cleansing, nor sanctified by seas and rivers, nor washed by any ablution. It is by a spirit of uprightness and humility that his sin is atoned, and it is by the submission of his soul to all the statutes of God that his flesh is made clean when it is sprinkled with the water. The pages on The Washing in Living Water and The Voice in the Wilderness return to this. In the community's own law, a washing without a turned heart was only a bath.
The Two Spirits
Next stands the teaching that the instructor is to give to all the sons of light concerning the nature of all the children of men: the two spirits, of truth and of falsehood, in which every person walks until the time appointed. The fellowship has made this its second key teaching, and the page Children of Light sets it out in full. The article If All Is Appointed takes up the hard question it raises about freedom.
The Common Life
The middle of the scroll is practical. Those who enter separate themselves from the congregation of the men of falsehood and bind themselves by oath to return to the Law of Moses with a whole heart, according to all that has been revealed of it to the priests who keep the covenant and to the many. They are not to answer to the men of the pit, nor eat or drink anything of theirs, nor take anything from their hand except for a price.
Among themselves the lesser obeys the greater in matters of work and money. They shall eat in common, bless in common, and take counsel in common. Wherever there are ten men of the council of the community, a priest shall not be lacking among them, and he is the first to stretch out his hand to bless the bread and the new wine. Wherever there are ten, there shall not be lacking a man who studies the Law day and night. And the many shall keep watch together for a third of every night of the year, to read the book, to study the law, and to bless together.
There are rules for speaking. In the session of the many each sits in his rank and speaks in his turn. No one speaks in the middle of his fellow's words, before his brother has finished. No one speaks before one who is ranked ahead of him. A man who has something to say to the many stands on his feet and says: I have a word to speak to the many. If they tell him to speak, he speaks.
And there is a rule for correction, which the fellowship thinks the wisest thing in the scroll. Let each rebuke his fellow in truth, humility, and loving kindness. Let him not speak to him in anger or with a stiff neck. Let him not hate him in his heart, but rebuke him on the very day, and so not carry guilt because of him. And let no one bring a matter against his fellow before the many unless he has first rebuked him before witnesses. The article Was Jesus an Essene? notes how closely the gospel of Matthew follows these steps.
The Entry
The Rule gives the stages of admission exactly, and the page Qumran and the Desert summarizes them. The candidate is examined by the overseer at the head of the many, as to his understanding and his deeds. If he is fit, he is brought into the covenant and taught the rules. Later he stands before the many and they decide by lot, which here means by their vote, whether he shall draw near. For a first full year he does not touch the purity of the many or share in their property. He is examined again. In the second year he may touch the purity of the many, and his property and his earnings are handed to the overseer and entered in the account, but not yet spent for the many, and he does not touch their drink. When the second year is complete he is examined a third time, and if the lot falls for him he is inscribed among his brothers in the order of his rank, for the Law, for judgment, for purity, and for the mingling of his property; and his counsel and his judgment belong to the community.
Notice that his property was held in a separate account for a year. If he left, or was refused, he could take it with him. The community was strict. It was not grasping.
The Penalties
A list of faults and penalties follows. Some are grave. The man who lies knowingly about his property is cut off from the purity of the many for a year and loses a quarter of his food. The man who utters the holy Name, for any reason at all, is sent away and does not return. So is the man who slanders the many, and the man who has been ten years in the community and then betrays it.
Most are small, and the Qumran page lists some of them: for interrupting, for sleeping in the assembly, for foolish laughter, for a grudge. There are others of the same kind. Thirty days for spitting into the midst of the assembly. Ten days for waving the left hand about while talking. Ten days for leaving the session three times without cause. Six months for going naked before a companion when there is no need.
The fellowship does not keep these, as we have said. But read the list again and notice what nearly all of them protect. They are not about food laws or sacrifices. They are about what one person does to another's attention in a shared room: interrupting, dozing, laughing over someone's words, storming out, nursing a grievance. The community had learned what every household learns, that a common life is destroyed less often by great sins than by small discourtesies repeated daily.
The Council and the Wilderness
Then the Rule rises. In the council of the community there shall be twelve men and three priests, perfect in all that is revealed of the whole Law, to practice truth, righteousness, justice, loving kindness, and walking humbly each with his fellow. When these exist in Israel, the council of the community shall be established in truth as an eternal planting, a holy house for Israel and a most holy dwelling for Aaron, a tested wall, a precious cornerstone whose foundations shall not shake.
Here stands the charter verse: they shall separate from the dwelling of the men of iniquity and go into the wilderness to prepare there the way of the Lord, as it is written, in the wilderness prepare the way. Here too the community says what has replaced the altar. They shall atone for guilt and unfaithfulness without the flesh of burnt offerings and the fat of sacrifice; the offering of the lips, rightly made, shall be as a fragrance of righteousness, and perfection of way as a pleasing freewill gift. And here is the single line on which a great deal of study has been spent: they shall be ruled by the first statutes until the coming of the prophet and the anointed ones of Aaron and Israel. The article Two Anointed Ones is about that line.
The Closing Hymn
The scroll does not end with a rule. It ends with a song, in the first person. The singer blesses God at the times that God has decreed: at the beginning of the dominion of light, and at its turning, when it withdraws to its appointed place; at the beginning of the watches of darkness, and when the lights shine out from the holy height. As long as I live, he says, an engraved statute shall be on my tongue as a fruit of praise.
And then, from a member of the strictest community in Israel, this: as for me, my judgment is with God. In his hand is the perfection of my way and the uprightness of my heart. If I stumble, the mercies of God shall be my salvation always. If I stagger because of the sin of flesh, my judgment shall be by the righteousness of God, which stands forever. For no one is master of his own way. He is a shape of molded clay, and his longing is for the dust.
The fellowship asks students who are troubled by the ranks and the penalties to read the scroll to the end before they judge it. The people who wrote the list of faults also wrote this. They kept a hard rule, and they did not think the rule would save them. The article Discipline Is Not Merit says why that matters.
How the Fellowship Reads It
We read it as a window and not as a law, as the Dead Sea Scrolls page has said. We do not rank, examine, expel, or curse, and we would not if we could. The hatred of outsiders that runs through the scroll we leave where we found it, and the page on How We Read explains why reading honestly means saying so.
What we have taken is this: the hours of prayer at the turning of the light and the dark; the examination of the heart; the nightly reading; the rule of speaking in turn and of rebuking on the same day and without anger; and the opening sentence, that a person brings her knowledge, her powers, and her possessions, and that all three need purifying. The page Reading Together uses the Rule's order of speaking for students who meet in twos and threes.
A student might try the opening sentence for a week as an examination at the Evening Watch. What did I know today, and whom did it serve? What was I able to do today, and whom did it serve? What did I have today, and whom did it serve? Most of us will find that we are generous in one of the three and tight-fisted in the other two. The Rule asked for all three, in that order.