History

The Shape of the House

What the walls and doorways of Qumran say about the people who built them, and what a student's own house says about her.

"A holy house for Israel, a most holy dwelling for Aaron."

After the Community Rule

A building is a kind of sentence. Its walls say who may come in, its doors say how far, and its largest room says what its builders thought most important. People can be careless in what they write. They are rarely careless in where they put a wall, because a wall costs labor, and no one hauls stone in the heat of the Dead Sea for a wall he does not need.

The page on Qumran and the Desert describes what stands on the terrace: the tower, the long hall, the pantry, the kilns, the cisterns and stepped pools. This page asks a different question of the same stones. Leaving aside what was found in the rooms, what does the arrangement of the rooms themselves say?

Reading a Ground Plan

In our own century an archaeologist of the land put that question to Qumran in a formal way. The method is used on ruins of every period, and it sets aside pottery and coins and looks only at the plan. Every room is treated as a point, and every doorway as a line joining two points. Then one counts. How many doorways must a person pass to reach each room from the entrance? Which rooms open onto several others, and which onto only one? Where can a single person, standing in a single passage, see and control everyone who comes and goes?

A house planned for meeting has rooms that open onto many other rooms, and more than one way to get anywhere. People cross one another's paths in it whether they mean to or not. A house planned for separation is shaped like a tree. Each room hangs from one branch only, there are no ways around, and a person goes exactly where he is permitted and nowhere else.

What the Plan Shows

Qumran is a tree. The study found the settlement divided into several blocks of rooms, each joined to a central passage that controls it, with very few doorways from one block to another. Within each block the rooms are again joined as sparingly as possible. To reach most of the rooms from any starting point, a person had to cross several thresholds in a fixed order, and there was no second way.

The large rooms are the most striking. The long hall where the community is thought to have eaten, and the room where the inkwells were found, are not near the entrance and cannot be seen from it. A stranger who came in at the gate by the tower would not have known they were there. They lie deep in the plan, behind turnings. And the stepped pools tend to stand at the joints, at the places where one passes from one part of the house to another, so that the plan seems to say: before you go further in, go down into the water.

The study drew two conclusions. The plan divided the inhabitants from one another, so that chance meetings were few and gatherings happened only where and when they were meant to. And, more strongly, it divided the inhabitants from the world outside. What the building expressed, the study said, was an ethos of social segregation.

The Rule in Stone

Set that beside the Community Rule and the two fit closely. The Rule admits a candidate by degrees. For a first year he lives alongside the community and may not touch the purity of the many, which seems to mean their common food. For a second year he may touch the food but not the drink. Only after that is he inscribed among his brothers. A house in which the dining hall lay several thresholds deep, each threshold with its pool, is exactly the house such a rule would need. A man's place in the community could be measured by how far in he was allowed to walk.

There was a greater house built on the same principle, and every member knew it. The temple in Jerusalem was a set of courts one within another: an outer court where anyone might walk, then a court for the women of Israel, then one for the men, then the court of the priests with the altar, then the holy place, and last the holy of holies, which one man entered on one day of the year. Holiness, in that building, meant distance traveled inward. The community believed the temple defiled, and the Rule says what they put in its place: the council of the community itself was to be a holy house for Israel and a most holy dwelling for Aaron, which are the names of the temple's two inner chambers. They had become the temple. It is not surprising that they built their house in its shape.

Cautions

A plan is not a diary, and the fellowship offers three cautions. A fort, a storehouse, and a rich man's farm also control who goes where, for reasons that have nothing to do with holiness, and some scholars read Qumran in just those ways; the page The Qumran Question sets out their arguments. The settlement was rebuilt more than once over a century and a half, and a plan that grew by additions may express no single intention. And a count of doorways cannot tell us what the people who used them felt. The study is one piece of evidence. It carries weight because it agrees with the Rule, the pools, and the witnesses, and not because it could stand alone.

The Other House

There is something in the plan to admire and something to grieve.

What we admire is the knowledge that an inner life needs an inner room. The desert community understood that what is open to everything is soon filled with everything, and that a people who meant to study a third of every night needed walls between themselves and the market. The page Keeping the Door speaks of the house swept and left empty. The builders of Qumran did not leave theirs empty, and they knew where its doors were.

What we grieve is the same thing seen from the road. A house in which every room hangs from a single branch has no place where a stranger can wander in. The teacher of the Way kept the inner room; the gospels show him again and again going apart to pray, and telling his followers to go into their room and shut the door. But the house he is remembered in is the other kind. People came in through the roof. A woman of the town walked in off the street while he was at table. The article The Table of the Messiah sets the two tables side by side. The two ground plans say the same thing in stone.

A Practice: Walking the House

Every student lives in a house with a plan, even if it is one room. The fellowship suggests that she walk it once, slowly, as the archaeologist walked Qumran, and ask the same questions.

  • How far in can a stranger come? Is there a table where someone who is not family has eaten this year?
  • Is there an inner room? Is there one place, a chair, a corner, a shelf with a lamp on it, that is kept for the watch and for nothing else?
  • What stands at the thresholds? The community put water there. What does she pass on the way in each evening, and does it make her more ready to enter or less?
  • Which room is largest, and what is it for?

Most houses, walked this way, turn out to be all door or all wall. A house that is all door has no inner room, and its people are tired. A house that is all wall has no table for the stranger, and its people are alone. The fellowship does not think the answer is the same for every student. We think only that the plan should be chosen and not merely inherited, and that it should have, somewhere in it, both a door that shuts and a door that opens. The practice on the Gate of the Essenes page, of pausing on the threshold going out and coming in, is a way of keeping both in mind.