The historian counted the Essenes as one of the three great schools of his nation. The philosopher numbered them at four thousand. They lived in Jerusalem and in the towns of Judea in the very years the gospels describe. And the New Testament, which names Pharisees and Sadducees some hundred times between them, does not name the Essenes once.
The article Was Jesus an Essene? begins from this silence. This article does something smaller. It goes through the places where careful readers have thought they could make out the Essenes behind the text, though the name is absent, and weighs each one.
Why the Silence
Three explanations have been offered, and they do not exclude one another.
The first is that the Essenes were not there to be named. The gospels name the people Jesus argued with, and he argued in synagogues, in the temple courts, and at dinner tables. A people who would not eat with outsiders, and who held the temple defiled, did not turn up in those places to dispute. Nor, it has been pointed out, do they appear among those who brought him to trial. The parties that tried him are named. The Essenes had no seat on that council and no part in that night.
The second is that they are present under other names. Some have looked for them among the scribes, or the Herodians, on the ground that Herod favored the Essenes, as the story of Menahem tells. Neither guess has won much support.
The third is that they were too near to be seen: that many of the first followers came from among them or from the edges of their movement, and that the gospels have no word for them for the same reason a household has no word for itself. This cannot be shown, and it is the explanation the fellowship would most like to be true, which is a reason to be careful with it.
The Man with the Jar
On the day of the last supper Jesus sends two disciples into the city with a sign: a man carrying a jar of water will meet you; follow him. Drawing water was the work of women. A man with a jar on his shoulder would have stood out in a festival crowd, and it has been argued that such a man would most likely have come from a household without women or servants, and that the celibate Essenes of the city were such a household. The page The Gate of the Essenes sets this beside the gate and the upper room and weighs them together.
The argument is neat, and it is no more than that. The gospel presents the man as a prearranged signal, chosen because it was unusual. A signal need not belong to any party.
A Great Many of the Priests
The Acts of the Apostles reports that in the first years in Jerusalem the number of disciples multiplied greatly, and a great many of the priests became obedient to the faith. Some have asked who these priests could have been. The Sadducees, the party of the high priests, were the chief opponents of the new movement. The Pharisees were mostly laymen. The one priestly movement at odds with the temple authorities and hungry for a renewal was the Essenes, whose leaders called themselves the sons of Zadok. So, the argument runs, these converts were Essene priests.
The weakness is in the arithmetic. There were many thousands of priests in the land, divided into twenty-four courses that came up to serve in the temple a week at a time. Most were poor men of the villages who belonged to no party at all, and who had as little love for the great priestly families as anyone. A great many of the priests could have joined the Way without one Essene among them. Still, the verse is a reminder of something easily forgotten: the first community in Jerusalem was full of priests, and whatever the Essenes had taught the priesthood to hope for, those men had heard.
Eunuchs for the Kingdom
When the disciples say that if marriage is so binding it is better not to marry, Jesus answers that there are those who have made themselves eunuchs for the sake of the kingdom of heaven; let the one who can receive it, receive it. Among Jews of that time, to remain unmarried for God's sake was almost unheard of. The command to be fruitful was the first in the Law. The only people known to have made a practice of it were the Essenes of the stricter order and their cousins by the lake. Whoever Jesus had in mind, his hearers had only one living example to think of.
The Sons of Light
In the gospel of Luke, at the end of the parable of the dishonest steward, Jesus says that the sons of this age are shrewder in dealing with their own kind than the sons of light. Sons of light was the desert community's own name for itself. A great Jewish scholar of the gospels proposed that Jesus was speaking of the Essenes here, and not kindly. The proposal needs room, and the article The Shrewd Steward gives it.
What Has Light to Do with Darkness
In the second letter to the Corinthians there is a paragraph that sits oddly in its place. Do not be yoked with unbelievers, it says. What partnership has righteousness with lawlessness? What fellowship has light with darkness? What accord has Christ with Belial? What has the temple of God to do with idols? For we are the temple of the living God. Therefore come out from among them and be separate, and touch nothing unclean.
Belial is the scrolls' name for the prince of darkness, and it appears nowhere else in the New Testament. The pairing of light and darkness, the community as temple, the summons to come out and be separate and touch nothing unclean: every phrase can be matched in the Community Rule. The paragraph interrupts the letter around it, which reads smoothly if it is lifted out. A number of scholars have concluded that Paul, or someone after him, is quoting or reworking a piece of teaching that came from Essene circles, turned to Christian use by the addition of a name.
The fellowship finds this the most persuasive case on the list, because it rests on words and not on guesses about persons. If it is right, there is a fragment in the New Testament that an Essene would have recognized as his own.
The Ascetics of Colossae
The letter to the Colossians warns its readers against those who would judge them in matters of food and drink, of festivals, new moons, and Sabbaths; who insist on self-abasement and the worship of angels, taking their stand on visions; whose rules are do not handle, do not taste, do not touch. Such things, the letter says, have an appearance of wisdom in self-made religion and severity to the body, but are of no value against the indulgence of the flesh.
Critics of the Essenes have often pointed to this passage, and it is easy to see why. A strict calendar, rules of touching and tasting, hard treatment of the body, and a keen interest in angels are a fair description of the desert community from outside. One detail is closer still. The phrase worship of angels may mean not worship offered to angels but the worship that the angels themselves offer, which the visionary claims to have seen and joined. The caves held a cycle of songs for the Sabbath sacrifice that describe exactly that: the liturgy of the angelic priests in the heavenly temple, sung on earth by a community that believed it stood among them.
But Colossae is in Asia Minor, a long way from the Dead Sea, and the ancient world had many ascetics and many seers. The most that can be said is that the teaching the letter opposes was of an Essene kind. The warning itself the fellowship takes seriously, and the article Discipline Is Not Merit is our answer to it.
The Weighing
Set the cases in a row and a pattern appears. Wherever the argument depends on identifying a person, the man with the jar, the priests, it is weak; the person could always have been someone else. Wherever it depends on words, sons of light, Belial, the temple that is a people, the two spirits of truth and of error in the first letter of John, it is strong. The Essenes cannot be found in the New Testament as characters. They are in it as a vocabulary.
That is what one would expect if the Way grew in soil the Essenes had tilled, as the page on The Three Sects puts it. People who have left a house, or grown up beside it, do not go on speaking of the house. They go on speaking its language. And very often, as the article on Jesus shows, they use its language to say something the house would not have said: that the light is for the sons of darkness too.
The fellowship would add one caution for the student who enjoys this kind of search, as we do. It is easy, once one has learned to hear the Essene accent, to hear it everywhere, and to end by making the New Testament a book about the Essenes with the names removed. It is not. It is a book about someone else, written by people who had learned to speak in a country where the Essenes had long been talking. The silence about them is real. We should let it stay a silence, and listen to what was said.