Articles

Discipline Is Not Merit

A critic says the Essenes kept their hard rule to show God how much they loved him, and that it was worth nothing. A keeper of the hours answers, and agrees with more of it than she expected.

A student sent the fellowship the text of a talk given on Christian radio, and asked what we made of it. The talk is about the Essenes. It is brisk and not unkind, and partway through it says something I have not been able to put down.

The Essenes, the speaker says, ate in silence as an act of piety. They denied themselves as an act of piety. None of this is in the Law and none of it was ever asked of them by God. It is simply what people do when they want to please him: look how much I love you; I will not speak from this hour to that, I will make myself uncomfortable, and that is how you will know I am serious. And everyone else will think I am especially godly as well. The talk goes on to the letter to the Colossians, which warns against self-abasement and severity to the body as things that have an appearance of wisdom and are of no value against the indulgence of the flesh. We are not brought near to God, it concludes, by going without chocolate or coffee. We are brought near by what was done for us.

I have risen before the sun for twenty-two years, and I keep a weekly fast. So I read this as a person reads a letter about herself.

Where the Talk Is Right

The first thing to say is that the speaker knows something true about people like me.

There is a smugness that comes at five in the morning. I know it well. The house is dark, everyone else is asleep, and a small voice remarks that I am up and they are not. There is a fast that is kept so that one may know oneself to be the sort of person who fasts. There is a silence at table that is really a performance, with oneself as the audience. No one who has kept a discipline for long is innocent of these, and anyone who says she is has not been watching.

And the talk is right about the Essenes in particular, at least as a danger. A community that ranks its members every year by their deeds has built a ladder, and where there is a ladder people will look down. A community that calls itself the sons of light has already said what it thinks of the neighbors. The talk observes, dryly, that of course they were the sons of light and everyone else the sons of darkness. The page Under the Essene Name says the same in our own voice.

The talk is right, too, in the sentence from Colossians, and I can confirm it from experience. Severity to the body is of no value against the indulgence of the flesh. I have fasted until evening and been short with my husband before supper. I have kept the watch and gone straight from it to a grievance I had been nursing for a week. Going without does not change the heart. If it did, every hungry person would be a saint.

What the Essenes Said of Themselves

But there is a question the talk does not ask, and it is the one that matters. What did the Essenes think they were doing? A person may be wrong about someone's motives, and the surest way to find out is to listen to what they say when they pray.

We can do that now. The Community Rule is the strictest rule of life that has come down from that world, with its ranks and its fines, and it ends with a hymn. If the members had believed that their discipline earned them a place with God, the last page is where they would have said so. This is what they said instead. As for me, my judgment is with God. In his hand is the perfection of my way. If I stumble, the mercies of God shall be my salvation always. If I stagger because of the sin of flesh, my judgment shall be by the righteousness of God. By his mercies he has drawn me near.

The Thanksgiving Hymns say it over and over. I know that righteousness does not belong to a man, nor perfection of way to a son of man. To God Most High belong all the works of righteousness. I am a creature of clay. What am I, that you have taught me?

These are not the prayers of people who thought they were buying something. Whatever the Essenes got wrong, and they got some things badly wrong, they did not think their rule saved them. They kept it to the letter, and at the end of it they sang that they were brought near by mercy. In almost the very words the talk uses for the gospel, they had got there first. I do not say the speaker should have known this. The hymns are not much read. I say only that the picture of a man telling God to look how much he loves him is not the picture the caves have given us.

What Discipline Is For

Then why keep a rule at all? If it earns nothing and does not change the heart, what is it for?

I am a nurse, and I will answer as one. Before I change a dressing I wash my hands. I do not wash them to make the patient love me, or to show the charge nurse how careful I am, and the washing does not heal the wound. I wash them so that I can touch the wound without doing harm. It is not the treatment. It is what makes me fit to be near the treatment.

That is how I understand the hours. Rising before dawn does not earn the Light. The Light, as our Lection says, keeps its appointments whether I keep mine or not. I rise so as to be there when it comes. The fast does not make me holy. It makes me hungry, and a hungry person notices things that a full one does not, including how much of her kindness depends on having eaten. The silence is not a gift to God. He does not need my quiet. I need it, because I cannot hear anyone, him least of all, over the sound of my own commentary.

The letters of the New Testament know this difference. The same Paul under whose name the warning to the Colossians stands writes elsewhere that he disciplines his body and brings it under control, as a runner does, so as not to be disqualified; and he tells a younger man to train himself for godliness. The teacher of the Way fasted forty days in the wilderness before he said a word in public, and when he taught about fasting he did not say if you fast. He said when you fast, and then gave the one rule that settles the whole matter: do it in secret. Wash your face. Let no one know. That rule cuts the nerve of the thing the talk is afraid of, and it is the rule of our own page on Service and Kindness, where the best deeds are the ones no one sees.

Discipline is training. It is not payment. A person may train every day of her life and be owed nothing for it, and know that she is owed nothing, and go on training because of what it makes room for.

Five Signs That It Has Turned

The trouble is that from inside, training and payment feel much alike, and one slides into the other without a sound. Over the years I have collected five signs that the slide has happened in me.

  • I am keeping count. When I know exactly how many mornings in a row I have kept the watch, and feel the number as a possession, I have started a ledger. Ledgers are for debts.
  • I am looking down. If the thought of someone who sleeps until eight gives me any pleasure at all, the practice has soured.
  • I cannot break it for a person. The fellowship's rule is that the sheep comes out of the pit, as the article Was Jesus an Essene? puts it. When a child is ill or a friend telephones in tears and I resent them for costing me my hour, the hour has become an idol.
  • A missed day brings shame instead of return. If I miss the watch and feel like a failure, I had been keeping it to feel like a success. The page on The Way of Practice says that the practice is the returning. Shame is the sign that I thought it was the record.
  • It is hurting me. The fellowship's page on Fasting and Simplicity has its cautions, and they are there for a reason. A discipline that damages the body or frightens the people who love me is not severity in a good cause. It is the thing Colossians warns of, and it should stop.

When I find one of these, I do not give up the practice. I make it smaller and more hidden for a while, until it is training again.

A Test for the Kitchen

I will end with the plainest test I know, because the talk deserves a plain answer. It is not whether I rose, or how long I sat, or what I went without. It is whether the people who live with me find me easier to live with than they did a year ago. My husband is the judge of my Morning Watch. He has never once attended it.

If the answer is yes, then the discipline is doing its work, and I can thank God for it and take no credit, since I did not make the dawn. If the answer is no, then for all my early rising I have only been telling God to look how much I love him, and the speaker on the radio had me exactly right.

I am grateful for that talk. It is good, now and then, to be described by someone who does not admire you. The Essenes had three witnesses who thought them marvelous, and I sometimes think it did them no good. I would gladly set a place at our table for a fourth witness who was not so sure.