The story has been told so often that it has the polish of a legend, and parts of it probably are. In the winter of 1946 or 1947 some herdsmen of a Bedouin tribe were grazing their goats along the cliffs at the northwest corner of the Dead Sea. One of them, a boy, went looking for a stray. He came to a hole in the rock face, too small and too high to be a comfortable doorway, and threw a stone into it. Instead of a thud he heard something break. He was afraid, and ran. Later he came back with a companion, squeezed in, and found tall clay jars standing along the wall, most of them empty. From one of them he took some bundles wrapped in linen, black with age and foul to smell.
There were seven scrolls in all from that first cave. This page tells what became of them, how ten more caves were found, and why it took so long for the world to read what was in them.
The Dealers
The herdsmen took their bundles to Bethlehem and sold them, for very little, through a cobbler who also dealt in antiquities. Four of the scrolls were bought by the head of a Syrian monastery in Jerusalem. Three were bought by a professor of the Hebrew University, who traveled to Bethlehem by bus through a country sliding into war and read the first lines of a Hebrew no one had written for two thousand years. He recorded that he bought them on the very day the nations voted to divide the land.
The other four went to America with their owner, who could find no buyer. In 1954 they were offered for sale in a small advertisement in a New York newspaper, under the heading of miscellaneous items: biblical manuscripts dating back to at least 200 before the common era, an ideal gift to an educational or religious institution. They were bought, quietly, for the new state of Israel, and joined the other three. All seven are kept today in Jerusalem, under a white dome made in the shape of the lid of one of the jars.
The seven were the great Isaiah scroll, complete from the first chapter to the last; a second, more damaged Isaiah; the Community Rule; the commentary on Habakkuk; the Thanksgiving Hymns; the War Scroll; and a retelling of Genesis in Aramaic.
The Caves
Once it was understood what the scrolls were, the search began, and it was a race. On one side were archaeologists, who found the first cave again in 1949 and went on to dig the ruin on the terrace through the early fifties. On the other were the Bedouin, who knew the cliffs far better and had learned what a scrap of old leather was worth. The Bedouin won most of the heats. It was they who found, in 1952, the cave that mattered most: the fourth, cut into the soft marl a stone's throw from the ruin, its floor deep in fragments.
In the end eleven caves near the ruin gave up manuscripts. The first and the eleventh held scrolls nearly whole. The third held the strangest find, two rolls of copper sheet with a list of buried treasure punched into the metal, which had to be sawn into strips to be read and which no one has ever followed to a single coin. The fourth held no whole scroll at all. It held some fifteen thousand pieces, the wreck of more than five hundred manuscripts, which had been lying loose on the floor for nineteen centuries while damp and vermin did their work.
Because the fragments were bought by the piece, there are sad stories of larger pieces being torn to make more of them. The buyers learned to pay by the area instead.
The Puzzle
The fragments of the fourth cave were laid out under glass on long tables in a museum in Jerusalem, and a small team of scholars from several countries was appointed to sort them. Consider what they faced. It was as if hundreds of jigsaw puzzles had been emptied onto one floor, most of the pieces of each thrown away, and the boxes with their pictures burned. They sorted by the handwriting of the scribe, by the color and thickness of the skin, by the ruled lines, by the shape of a tear that matched the shape of another tear. Many of the pieces were smaller than a postage stamp. A single letter on the edge of a scrap could settle which of two books it came from.
The work was heroic, and it was also far too slow. The team was small, guarded its fragments closely, and published at the pace of a generation. Forty years after the fourth cave was found, most of its texts could still be read only by a few dozen people. In the early nineties the photographs were at last opened to everyone, with some bitterness on all sides, and within another ten years the whole library was in print. Today any student can look at the fragments themselves, photographed in many kinds of light, without leaving her kitchen. The fellowship thinks this one of the quiet wonders of the age.
What Was Found
In round numbers, the caves held the remains of some nine hundred manuscripts or more, the count depending on how the fragments are grouped. Most are written on leather, some on papyrus, and one on copper. Most are in Hebrew, a good number in Aramaic, and a few in Greek. They were copied over about three hundred years, from the third century before the common era to the first century of it. They fall into three rough kinds.
- About a quarter are copies of the books that became the Hebrew scriptures. The page The Scriptures of the Caves says what they have taught us.
- Another part are religious writings that many Jews of the age read and that later generations set aside or lost, such as the books of Enoch and Jubilees.
- The remainder are the writings of the community itself: its rules, hymns, calendars, and commentaries. The page on The Dead Sea Scrolls introduces them.
Earlier Findings
The herdsmen were not the first. A Christian scholar of the third century, gathering every version of the scriptures he could find, noted that one of his texts had been found in a jar near Jericho. About the year 800 a bishop of the Eastern church wrote to a friend that books had been found in a cave near Jericho when a hunter's dog went in after an animal, and that Jews from Jerusalem had gone out and recovered many of them. And the Damascus Document was read in Cairo fifty years before the caves, in two medieval copies whose source no one could then explain. The desert had been giving back its library a little at a time for seventeen hundred years. In the last century it gave the rest.
Still Being Read
The finding is not over. The skins have been tested for their age, and the results have broadly confirmed what students of handwriting had already judged. More recently the genetic traces left in the leather have been used to tell which fragments came from the same animal, and so from the same scroll. And in the last few years researchers have trained a machine to compare the handwriting of dated and undated scrolls, and have proposed that a number of the manuscripts are older than had been thought. That proposal is new and is not yet generally accepted. The fellowship reports it as a proposal.
What we would have the student notice is how the thing was done. A stone thrown by a boy, and then eighty years of patient people fitting scraps together, arguing over single letters, and publishing their photographs so that others could check. The page The Modern Essene Gospels gives four questions to ask of any book that claims an ancient source. The scrolls are what it looks like when the answer to all four is yes. There is a manuscript. Anyone may see it. We know how it was found. And it says a great many things that no one in our age would have wished it to say.
The Jars
The jars of the first cave are unlike ordinary storage jars. They are tall and straight, with wide mouths and bowl-shaped lids, and the same kind were found in the ruin on the terrace. Whoever put the scrolls into them had wrapped each one in linen first.
That is the detail the fellowship keeps. With a Roman army on the road, someone took the time to wrap a book in linen, lower it into a jar, fit the lid, and carry it up a cliff. They could not have known whether anyone would ever come for it. No one did, for nineteen hundred years. And then a boy threw a stone. The article Will It Hold? has more to say about jars. Here it is enough to say that the scrolls are not only a library. They are an act of trust by people who expected to die, addressed to readers they could not imagine, and we are the readers.