Until the caves were opened, everything the world knew of the Essenes came from three men who wrote in the first century of the common era. These pages call them the philosopher, the historian, and the naturalist, and lean on them constantly. A student who leans on witnesses should know something about them: where each stood, what each wanted, and what each was in a position to see. A witness is not a window. He is a person standing at a window, and the view depends on where he stands.
The article Who Were the Essenes? sets the three accounts side by side and marks where they agree and where they differ. This page is about the men themselves.
The Philosopher
The oldest of the three was a Jew of Alexandria in Egypt, born some twenty years before the common era into one of the wealthiest families of that city. He wrote in Greek, and he spent his life showing that the Law of Moses and the best of Greek philosophy taught the same truths. In his old age he led a delegation of the Jews of Alexandria to the emperor in Rome, to plead for his people after a season of riots. He was at least once in Jerusalem, where he says he went up to the temple to pray and to offer sacrifice.
He wrote of the Essenes twice. The first account stands in a treatise arguing that every good man is free and every bad man a slave, where the Essenes are brought forward as living proof. The second stood in a defense of the Jews that is now lost, and survives only because a church historian of the fourth century copied a long passage of it into a book of his own. He also wrote the only description we have of the contemplatives by the lake in Egypt, whom the article The Healers of the Lake describes.
What he gives us is precious. He is the one who numbers the Essenes at more than four thousand. He says they lived in villages, working the land and practicing crafts that serve peace, and that no maker of arrows, spears, or swords could be found among them. He says there was not a single slave among them, and that they condemned the owners of slaves as breakers of the law of nature, which bore and nursed all alike as a mother. He says they had one purse, one table, and one store of clothing, and that the sick and the old were cared for from what was held in common. And he sums up their whole teaching in three rules: the love of God, the love of virtue, and the love of humankind.
What must be weighed is his purpose. He was writing for educated Greeks, and he wanted them to see that a Jewish community had achieved the freedom from passion their own philosophers only talked about. So his Essenes are a little too calm. They have no quarrel with the temple, no calendar of their own, no war of light against darkness, no curses on the men of the pit. He does not lie. He selects, as an advocate selects, and what he leaves out is nearly everything the scrolls later put back.
The Historian
The second witness was born in Jerusalem in the year 37 of the common era, to a family of priests. He tells us in the account of his own life that at about sixteen he resolved to try the three schools of his people in turn, passed through all three with hard discipline, and then spent three years in the wilderness with the hermit Bannus, before returning to the city at nineteen to live by the rule of the Pharisees. When the war with Rome began he was given command of the revolt in Galilee. He was besieged, captured, and brought before the Roman general, to whom he foretold that he would be emperor. Two years later the general was emperor, and the prisoner was a free man with a patron. He watched Jerusalem fall from the Roman lines, and he wrote all his books in Rome.
He describes the Essenes at length in his history of the war, written within ten years of the temple's fall, and more briefly in the long history of his people that he finished more than twenty years after the temple fell. He names individual Essenes, whom the page Essenes Known by Name gathers. Nearly every concrete detail on this site comes from him: the prayers toward the dawn, the cold bath and the linen, the silent meal, the hatchet and the apron given to the novice, the oath, the ranks, the avoidance of oil, the refusal to spit into the midst of the company, the second order who married.
He is the best witness we have, and three cautions go with him. The first is arithmetic. If he tried three schools and then lived three years with a hermit, all between sixteen and nineteen, there was no room for the Essene novitiate, which by his own account took three years by itself. He knew the Essenes as an inquirer knows a house he has visited, perhaps as a candidate in his first months, not as one who had sworn the oath and eaten at the table. The second is his audience. He calls the three schools philosophies and likens the Essenes to the followers of Pythagoras, because those were words his Roman readers understood, and the article on the soul notes where the Greek dress shows. The third is his situation. He was a defeated general writing under the roof of the men who had destroyed his city. It suited him to show that the best of his people were quiet, disciplined, and no threat to anyone, and that the war had been the work of a violent few. The page The Fourth Philosophy tells where he laid the blame.
And yet the scrolls have been kind to him. Small things he reports, which no one could check for nineteen centuries, turned up in the Community Rule when it was unrolled: the stages of entry, the common purse, the priest's blessing before the meal, even the rule against spitting in the assembly. A witness who is right about spitting has earned a hearing on larger matters.
The Naturalist
The third witness was a Roman officer and administrator who spent his nights compiling an encyclopedia of the whole natural world in thirty-seven books. He finished it about the year 77 and dedicated it to the emperor's son, the general who had taken Jerusalem. Two years later, commanding the fleet in the bay of Naples, he sailed toward the erupting mountain to see it more closely and to bring off survivors, and died on the shore.
His notice of the Essenes is a single paragraph in his description of Judea, between the river Jordan and the balsam of Jericho. On the west of the Dead Sea, he writes, far enough from the shore to escape its harm, lives the solitary people of the Essenes, marvelous beyond all others in the world: without women, having renounced all desire, without money, with only the palm trees for company. Day by day their number is renewed by the throng of those whom weariness of life and the tides of fortune drive to adopt their ways. So, through thousands of ages, incredible to say, a people endures into which no one is born. Below them, he adds, was the town of Engedi, and beyond it the rock fortress of Masada.
He almost certainly never saw them. He worked from the reports of others, as he did for most of the world, and his thousands of ages are a flourish. But his paragraph is the only one of the three accounts that puts the Essenes at a place on the map, and the place is the western shore of the Dead Sea, north of Engedi, which is where the ruins of Qumran stand. On that one sentence the identification of the ruins has largely rested, as the page The Qumran Question explains.
The Later Voices
A few later writers add a little. A Greek orator of the end of the first century is reported to have praised the Essenes as a whole and blessed city beside the Dead Sea. A churchman of Rome in the third century repeats the historian's account with changes of his own, some of which may come from another source; the article He Will Make the Dead Live considers one of them. The bishop of Salamis, in the fourth century, knows the name only as one item in a catalogue of sects, as The Bishop's Catalogue sets out. By then no one writing had met an Essene.
The Two Silences
Two bodies of writing that might have named the Essenes never do. The New Testament names Pharisees and Sadducees on almost every page of the gospels and the Essenes not once; the article Unnamed in the Gospels weighs the places where readers have thought they stand behind the text. And the great collections of the rabbis, compiled in the centuries after the war, speak of Pharisees and Sadducees and of various heretics, but have no word that plainly means Essene. Perhaps they are there under another name. Perhaps a people who had withdrawn from the common life of Israel were simply not part of the story the rabbis had to tell. Withdrawal has a price, and one part of the price is being forgotten.
How the Fellowship Uses Them
We have three working rules. Where the three agree, though they wrote in different cities for different readers, we take it as solid ground: the common purse, the strict life, the small number, the apartness. Where one of them is confirmed by the scrolls, we trust him on that point and a little more on the next. And where a witness tells us what suited his purpose, we hold it more loosely: the philosopher's untroubled calm, the historian's Greek doctrine of the soul and his picture of a people with no part in the war, the naturalist's endless ages.
Then we remember what all three have in common. They were outsiders, and all three admired what they saw. Each stood at his own window and described a people he could not join. The fellowship stands at a window too. The difference the caves have made is that we can now hear, faintly, what was being said inside the house, and the pages on The Dead Sea Scrolls and The Community Rule are where we listen.