Discernment

Memories of the Desert

On the books in which people under hypnosis remember lives among the Essenes: what they say, what can be checked, and why a memory is not a manuscript.

"Believe not every spirit, but try the spirits."

After the first letter of John

The page on The Modern Essene Gospels describes books that claim an ancient manuscript no one else has seen. In the last forty years a different kind of Essene book has appeared, and it makes a different kind of claim. There is no manuscript at all. The source is a living person lying on a couch in a quiet room, who has been led by a hypnotist into a relaxed state and asked to go back before her birth, and who begins to speak, in the first person and the present tense, as someone who lived beside the Dead Sea two thousand years ago.

Students ask the fellowship about these books more and more often. They are widely read, they are plainly sincere, and they are sold as a window onto exactly the things the scrolls leave dark. This page says how we weigh them.

What the Books Say

The first well-known book of the kind came from an American hypnotist near the end of the last century. Over many sessions one of her subjects spoke as an elderly Essene teacher at Qumran, who described the library and the daily round of the community and told how the young Jesus and his cousin John had been among his pupils.

Others followed, some of them encouraged by her. In one, published in our own century by two writers in the west of England, seven subjects are regressed in turn. One speaks as an Essene of a community west of the Dead Sea, the son of one of its elders. Another, to the hypnotist's astonishment, gives her name as Joseph of Arimathea, a merchant in tin and other metals who travels widely and visits the communities. The sessions describe a hidden core group of Essenes working around Jesus, links between the Essenes and the Druids of Britain, contacts with an Order of Melchizedek, and a teaching of the higher self and of many dimensions of being. They raise the question of whether Jesus died on the cross. And they are full of a great tenderness. Those who took part say that to be in the remembered presence of Jesus was a bliss they could hardly describe.

The fellowship does not doubt that they felt it. That is where the weighing has to begin.

Sincerity Is Not the Question

The people who make these books are not, as far as we can tell, deceiving anyone. The hypnotists record the sessions and transcribe them. The subjects are often surprised by what they say. One of the books records that no subject saw the transcript of another's sessions beforehand, and that its chief subject did not read the best-known earlier book until the main work was finished, which is the precaution of people trying to be careful.

But sincerity was never the test. The old monk in the story at the door of this room was sincere when he threw himself down the well. The first question of the room is not whether the speaker is honest. It is: who is answering? And for that question the couch is a difficult place, because what is known about memory under hypnosis is discouraging.

What Is Known About Such Memories

Those who study memory have tested hypnosis for a century, in courts and in laboratories, and their findings are steady. Hypnosis does not make memory more accurate. It makes the person more confident, more fluent, and more willing to fill a gap with something that fits. A subject who is asked a question in that state will generally produce an answer, and will afterward be unable to tell an answer she recovered from an answer she composed.

They have also traced a number of famous past-life memories to their sources. A woman who recalled, in vivid detail, a life in Roman Britain was found to be reproducing a historical novel she had read years before and forgotten, invented characters and all. The name for this is hidden memory. The mind keeps a great deal more of what it has read and heard than we can call up at will, and in the right state it will hand it back as experience, dressed in the first person, with no label saying where it came from.

And they have shown how much the questioner shapes the answer. In the published record of one of the Essene books, the hypnotist explains that she was hoping her subject would find an Essene life, and in the session it is she who first speaks the word. The subject has given a Hebrew-sounding name and a father's name. The hypnotist asks: is your community an Essene one? There is a long pause, and then: yes. Later she asks a second subject, who has identified herself as Joseph of Arimathea, whether she knows the first subject's character by name. Yes, comes the answer; he is my friend. The hypnotist writes that she had to stop herself from whooping for joy. A lawyer would call both of these leading questions. We do not say this to mock her. She was looking for something, and she asked for it by name, and the mind in front of her obliged, as minds in that state do.

What Can Be Checked

The second question of this room is: can you show me the page? Here, for once, there are pages. The scrolls exist. A memory of the Essenes can be laid beside what the Essenes wrote.

  • The Teacher. In one account a subject recalls an earlier life in the Damascus community, about a century before the common era, where the members were preparing for the coming of a great teacher, the Teacher of Righteousness, not knowing when he would come, and wrote down their rules for the guidance of other communities. The Damascus Document tells it the other way about. The Teacher had already come, had gathered the community, and had died, and the document counts the years since his gathering in. The page on The Teacher of Righteousness gives the passages.
  • The Jews. The remembered Essene says that his people feel like Essenes first and Jews second, and have little sympathy with Jews outside the brotherhood. The people of the scrolls did call outsiders the sons of darkness. But they did so because they held themselves to be the true Israel, the only ones keeping the covenant of Moses rightly. Their whole quarrel was over how to be Jews. A voice that sets Essene against Jew is speaking from our side of the centuries.
  • The vocabulary. The higher self, the many dimensions, unconditional love, energies, the clearing of blocks: these are the words of the spiritual movements of the late twentieth century, in which, by their own account, the authors and subjects had been at home for years. The scrolls speak of covenant, purity, the lot, the appointed time, the calendar, the sons of Zadok. The remembered Essenes hardly mention any of them.
  • The secrets. The remembered voices grow guarded just where an answer could be tested. Asked how many live in the community, the speaker says sharply that he is not permitted to tell. On matters no one can test, such as secret groups, journeys, and hidden meetings, they are generous.

The Layers Again

The article How a Tradition Grows digs through the Essene tradition layer by layer. What is striking about the remembered lives is that nearly everything in them comes from the upper layers and nothing from the bedrock.

That Joseph of Arimathea was a merchant in tin who traveled to Britain is a tale of the west of England, told around an abbey in the Middle Ages and given its tin trade by later folklore. That Jesus survived the cross and was nursed by Essenes is the story of the German pamphlet of the nineteenth century. The wise Druids who shared a secret teaching with the East belong to the romantic revival of the eighteenth century. The orders of hidden adepts are from the lodges and the theosophists. The Essene mystery school with its degrees is from the same shelf. All of these were in print, and in the air of every esoteric bookshop, long before the first session was recorded.

And what is absent is everything that surprised the scholars when the scrolls were first unrolled: the calendar of three hundred and sixty-four days, the two anointed ones, the penalties for spitting and for laughing, the latrine outside the camp, the hatred of the men of the pit. No remembered Essene, so far as we know, has ever recalled something that was unknown when the session took place and was later found in a fragment. That would be evidence. Its absence, after forty years of such books, is evidence too.

What We Do Not Say

We do not say that the soul cannot have lived before. The fellowship neither teaches nor denies it, as the teaching of The Soul and Its Journey explains, and this page is not an argument about reincarnation. A person might hold that souls return and still conclude that these particular memories are made of reading.

We do not say that nothing happened in those rooms. People wept. Old griefs loosened. Some went home kinder. An experience can be real as an experience, and can even do good, without being a report of the first century.

And we do not say that the people involved are fools or frauds. They wanted, very much, to be near Jesus, and to know the things the gospels do not tell. So does the fellowship. So did the people who wrote the modern gospels, and the seer who described the maidens of Carmel. The longing is the same in every generation. It is what a person does with the longing that this room is concerned with.

A Memory Is Not a Manuscript

The fellowship's rule is short. A memory is not a manuscript. Whatever comes from the couch, the cards, the trance, or our own Still Lamp, belongs to the person it came to. It may console her. It may show her something about her own heart. It is not history, and it must not be handed to another student as history, because that student cannot check it and has no way to tell it from a dream.

This is a rule we keep for ourselves first. Members of the fellowship have had, in the stillness, impressions of the desert so vivid that they seemed like recollection. We have written none of them on these pages. What we have written, we can show: this the historian says, this is in the Rule, this is the fellowship's own and is marked as ours.

For the student who has been moved by one of these books, we suggest three things. Keep what made you kinder. Read the Community Rule itself, which is stranger and harder than any remembered Essene and has the advantage of having been written by one. And when a voice tells you, from a couch or from anywhere else, something about the first century that you badly want to be true, ask it the question the room is built on. Not: is this beautiful? It may well be. Ask: can you show me the page?