The word messiah is a Hebrew word spelled in Greek letters, and it means anointed. In the scriptures of Israel a person was set apart for an office by having oil poured on the head. Kings were anointed. So were high priests. Once or twice a prophet is. For most of the centuries the Bible covers, to speak of the Lord's anointed was to speak of whoever was king or high priest at the time. The word did not yet mean a savior at the end of days. It meant a man with oil on his head and a task.
That older meaning is the key to one of the most surprising things in the scrolls. A student who comes to them from the gospels expects to find the hope of a messiah. She finds the hope of two.
The Line in the Rule
The Community Rule says that the members shall be governed by the first statutes in which the men of the community began to be instructed, until the coming of the prophet and the anointed ones of Aaron and Israel. Three figures. A prophet, perhaps the prophet like Moses whom Deuteronomy promises. An anointed one of Aaron, which is to say a priest. And an anointed one of Israel, a lay ruler, the king.
Other scrolls fill in the picture. One text from the fourth cave is a single sheet on which someone has copied out, one after another, a short chain of passages from the Law: the promise of a prophet like Moses; the oracle of the star that shall come out of Jacob and the scepter that shall rise out of Israel; and the blessing of Levi, the priestly tribe. Prophet, king, priest, each with his proof text, on one page, like a card carried in the pocket.
The royal figure is called by several names: the Messiah of Israel, the Prince of the Congregation, the Branch of David. He will judge the poor with righteousness and strike the earth with the rod of his mouth. The priestly figure is sometimes called the Interpreter of the Law. And whenever the two appear together, the priest is first. In the meal of the last days described in the Rule of the Congregation, as the article The Table of the Messiah recounts, the Messiah of Israel does not put out his hand to the bread until the priest has blessed it.
Where the Two Came From
They came from scripture. When the exiles returned from Babylon, the community was led by two men, a governor of the house of David and a high priest of the house of Zadok. The prophet Zechariah saw them in a vision as two olive trees standing either side of a golden lampstand, and was told: these are the two sons of oil who stand by the Lord of the whole earth. Jeremiah promises in one breath that David shall never lack a man to sit on the throne, and that the Levitical priests shall never lack a man to offer sacrifice. A reader who took those promises seriously would expect both lines to be restored at the end.
And they came, I think, from history. The page Before the Desert tells how the Hasmonean family took the high priesthood without belonging to the line of Zadok, and then took the crown without belonging to the line of David, and joined both in one man. The community of the scrolls was born out of the shock of that. Its hope for the end is the mirror image of what it had seen: not one man holding two offices to which he had no right, but two men, each in his own office by right, and the priest above the king. Their picture of the last days was a correction of their own.
Not One Doctrine
It would be tidy to stop there, but the scrolls are not tidy. The Damascus Document speaks, in the copies we have, of the anointed one of Aaron and Israel, in the singular, and scholars still dispute whether that means one figure or two. Another scroll gives the leading part in the last days to a heavenly being, Melchizedek, who proclaims liberty to the captives and makes atonement for the sons of light at the end of the tenth jubilee. A fragment in Aramaic speaks of one who will be called son of God and son of the Most High, in words very close to those of the angel's announcement in the gospel of Luke; whether it means a savior or a tyrant who claims those titles is disputed. Another fragment, which the article He Will Make the Dead Live discusses, speaks of an anointed one whom heaven and earth obey.
A historian of the New Testament has cautioned, rightly, that hopes of this kind were not peculiar to the Essenes. Many groups held many pictures, in part because priests and prophets as well as kings were anointed, and the scriptures could be read to promise any of them. What the caves show is not a creed but a whole workshop of expectation: a people so certain that God would act that they collected every way he might.
The Answer of the Way
The first followers of Jesus made a different claim, and it is easier to see how bold it was once one knows the scrolls. They said that the offices had met in one person.
He was the son of David, the king; the first gospel opens with his genealogy to prove it. He was the prophet like Moses; Peter says so in the temple court, quoting the same promise from Deuteronomy that stands first on the single sheet from the cave. And he was a priest. This was the hard part, because everyone knew he was of the tribe of Judah, of which Moses said nothing about priests. The letter to the Hebrews faces the difficulty squarely and solves it by reaching past Aaron altogether, to the priest-king of Genesis who blessed Abraham: a priest forever, after the order of Melchizedek. It is the same figure the desert community had set at the center of one of its own scrolls.
So the two movements read the same promises and drew the lines differently. One kept priest and king apart, and waited. The other said that priest, king, and prophet had come as one man, and that he had exercised all three offices from a cross. The fellowship does not ask its students to adjudicate between them. We ask them to see that both were answering the same question, in the same language, out of the same books.
Let the Priest Go First
The fellowship's fifth teaching, The Inner Kingdom, speaks of the heart as a temple and the mind as its priest. I have found it useful to carry the picture a step further, with the two anointed ones in mind.
Each of us holds two offices. There is the one in us who rules: who decides, plans, spends, manages a household or a department, gets things done. And there is the one in us who stands before God: who blesses, gives thanks, listens, and offers the day. The king and the priest. In most lives the king is busy from morning to night, and the priest is consulted, if at all, when the king is in trouble.
The desert community had one firm rule about the two. The priest goes first. The king does not reach for the bread until the blessing has been said. It is the order of the Morning Watch, which puts the prayer before the day's first task, and of the grace before a meal. It can be the order of smaller things too. Before a decision of any weight, before the difficult letter is written or the hard conversation begun, let the priest put out his hand first. A breath, a blessing, a moment of asking. Then let the king do his work.
The Hasmoneans joined the two offices by force and lost both. The scrolls kept them apart and waited for heaven to send the right men. The gospel says they are joined rightly in one who took the lowest place. For a student the joining is simply a matter of order, kept daily: blessing first, and then the bread.