History

The Teacher of Righteousness

The unnamed priest who gathered the desert community: what the scrolls say of him, who opposed him, and what he was not.

"To him God made known all the mysteries of the words of his servants the prophets."

After the commentary on Habakkuk

Every community has a beginning, and at most beginnings there is a person. The community of the scrolls remembered such a person and never once wrote down his name. They called him the Teacher of Righteousness, which may also be rendered the righteous teacher or the one who teaches rightly. Everything we know of him comes from a few lines of the Damascus Document, from the commentaries on Habakkuk, on Micah, and on the Psalms, and perhaps from some of the Thanksgiving Hymns. No ancient witness outside the scrolls mentions him at all.

This page gathers what those lines say, and marks carefully where saying ends and guessing begins.

What the Scrolls Say

He was a priest. The commentary on the Psalms calls him the Priest, the Teacher of Righteousness, whom God chose to stand before him and established to build for him a congregation. He arose, the Damascus Document says, after a root of planting had groped for the way for twenty years, and God raised him up to guide them in the way of his heart. The page Before the Desert tells what the groping was about.

His gift was the reading of scripture. The commentary on Habakkuk says that God told the prophet to write down what would come upon the last generation, but did not make known to him when the time would be fulfilled; and that the meaning was given to the Teacher of Righteousness, to whom God made known all the mysteries of the words of his servants the prophets. The claim is a bold one. The prophets had written more than they understood, and the understanding had been kept for one man and for those who listened to him.

He gave rulings on the Law as well as readings of the prophets, and he gathered a people around both. The same commentary takes the famous line of Habakkuk, the righteous shall live by his faith, and applies it to all who keep the Law in the house of Judah, whom God will deliver from the house of judgment because of their toil and their faithfulness to the Teacher of Righteousness. Two centuries later Paul would build a great argument on the same verse. The desert community read it first, and read it of loyalty to a teacher.

The Wicked Priest

The Teacher had an enemy, whom the commentaries call the Wicked Priest. The title is a bitter pun: in Hebrew the words for the high priest and the wicked priest are nearly the same. He was, the commentary says, called by the name of truth when he first arose; but when he ruled over Israel his heart grew proud, and he forsook God and betrayed the statutes for the sake of riches. He robbed and heaped up the wealth of the men of violence. He defiled the sanctuary.

One scene is told with unusual sharpness. The Wicked Priest pursued the Teacher of Righteousness to the house of his exile, to swallow him up in the heat of his anger; and at the time appointed for rest, on the Day of Atonement, he appeared before them to confuse them and make them stumble on the day of fasting, their Sabbath of repose. The detail tells more than it means to. No high priest could have traveled on the Day of Atonement, when he was needed in the temple for the holiest rite of the year. He could travel because by his calendar it was an ordinary day. The two men kept the great fast on different days, and the one with soldiers chose the other's fast for his visit.

The commentary records the Wicked Priest's end with satisfaction: God gave him into the hand of his enemies, who took vengeance on his body of flesh.

The Man of the Lie

There was a second opponent, and he seems to have hurt more. The scrolls call him the Man of the Lie, the Scoffer, the Spouter of Lies, and he was not a priest in Jerusalem but a teacher within the movement itself, who rejected the Law in the midst of their whole congregation and led many away with him. The commentary reproaches a group it calls the house of Absalom, who kept silent when the Teacher was rebuked and did not help him.

So the community began, as many do, with a quarrel on two sides: against the powerful outside, and against a brother who took half the room with him. If some of the Thanksgiving Hymns are the Teacher's own, as many readers think, they carry the mark of it. The singer thanks God for making him a banner to the chosen and an interpreter of knowledge in wonderful mysteries. He also says that he was driven from his land like a bird from its nest, and that those who ate his bread lifted their heel against him.

Who Was He?

No one knows, and the honest student should be wary of anyone who is sure. The guesses turn on the identity of the Wicked Priest. The commonest holds that he was Jonathan, the brother of Judah the Maccabee, who took the high priesthood in 152 before the common era and later died a captive in the hands of his enemies; or else Simon, his brother and successor. On that reckoning the Teacher was active in the middle of the second century. Others have looked earlier, to the high priests who bought the office under the Syrian king, or later, to a Hasmonean king of the next century. A few have looked as late as the years just before the war with Rome, which the age of the manuscripts makes very hard to maintain. Some think the Wicked Priest was not one man but a title passed from one high priest to the next.

One proposal about the Teacher himself deserves mention for its neatness. The lists of high priests show a gap of seven years just before Jonathan took office. Someone must have served on the Day of Atonement in those years, and his name appears nowhere. Perhaps, some have suggested, the Teacher was that man: the last high priest of the old line, pushed aside by a soldier, his name struck from the record by the victors and left unwritten, out of reverence, by his own people. It cannot be proved. It would explain a good deal.

What He Was Not

When the scrolls were first published, some writers announced that the Teacher of Righteousness had been a first draft of Jesus: a messiah put to death by a wicked priest, whose followers awaited his return. The scrolls do not say so. They do not call the Teacher an anointed one. They do not say he was killed; the Damascus Document speaks only of the day of the gathering in of the Teacher of the Community, the ordinary phrase for a death. They attribute to him no rising, no atoning death, and no miracles. The community looked for anointed ones still to come, and the Damascus Document looks ahead to one who will teach righteousness at the end of days, which is a hope for the future and not a memory of the founder.

Students who have read certain modern books will meet the opposite mistake, in which the Essenes of an early generation are pictured waiting for the Teacher of Righteousness to arrive. In the scrolls he has already come and gone. The Damascus Document counts the years since his gathering in. The page Memories of the Desert says more about books of that kind.

What he was is remarkable enough. He was a priest who lost an argument with the powerful and built a people out of the loss. He taught them that scripture was addressed to them, now, and they went on reading it that way for two centuries after he was gone.

The Unwritten Name

The fellowship has often wondered why they never wrote his name. Fear is one answer, since his enemies had soldiers. Reverence is another. But we think the likeliest reason is the simplest, and it is in the Rule: in the Unity, a member's knowledge, powers, and possessions belonged to the whole. The man who founded such a community would hardly have exempted himself. He gave them his reading of the prophets, and they kept the reading and let the name go.

There is a discipline in that for anyone who teaches, and for anyone who learns. The page The Secret Chiefs tells of modern orders built on teachers whose names were everything and whose sources could not be found. The desert community is the other case: a source that can be read to this day, and a teacher who vanished into it. The keepers of the fellowship sign what they write, as the About page explains, because a reader today needs to know who is speaking. But we hope that what is true in these pages would stand as well without us. That is the test the Teacher set, whether he meant to or not.