The gospels give John who baptized very few lines of description, and two of them are about his clothes and his food. He wore a garment of camel's hair with a leather belt about his waist, and he ate locusts and wild honey. Readers have usually taken this as color: the rough dress of a prophet, the poor fare of the wilderness. The leather belt and the hairy garment are certainly meant to recall Elijah, who is described in the books of the Kings in the same words.
The article The Voice in the Wilderness weighs whether John was an Essene, and it touches on his diet twice, once on each side of the scale. Since it was written, the fellowship has read a proposal by a Catholic scholar of the scriptures that puts the food at the center of the question. This article sets the proposal out, weighs it, and corrects something we said before.
The Oath and the Outcast
The proposal begins with a passage of the historian that is easy to pass over. Describing the discipline of the Essenes, he says that those caught in serious faults are expelled from the order, and that the man who is cast out often comes to a most miserable end. For he is bound by his oaths and his habits, and cannot share the food of other people. So he eats grass, and his body wastes with hunger until he dies. For this reason, the historian adds, they have taken many back in compassion when they were at their last breath, judging that suffering to the edge of death was punishment enough.
The Community Rule shows what lay behind this. The member swore to take nothing from the hand of outsiders, and to eat and drink nothing of theirs. Food was the center of the community's purity; it was the last thing a candidate was admitted to and the first thing a wrongdoer was cut off from. A man who had sworn that oath and then found himself outside the walls was in a terrible position. The oath did not end when the membership did. He could not go to an inn or accept a meal at a farmhouse door. He could eat only what no other hand had prepared: what grew of itself.
The Hermit Again
The page Essenes Known by Name tells of Bannus, the hermit with whom the historian spent three years of his youth. Bannus, he says, wore clothing that grew on trees and ate only food that grew of itself, and washed often in cold water by day and night for purity's sake. The historian does not call him an Essene, and we said on that page that we do not know who he was.
Put beside the passage about the outcasts, Bannus looks less mysterious. Here is a man living alone in the wilderness of Judea who will not wear what another has woven or eat what another has cooked, and who keeps the Essene washings. He is what a man would be who had left the community, or been put out of it, and had gone on keeping his oath.
John's Table
Now look again at John. His clothing is hair and hide, the stuff of the desert. His food is locusts and wild honey: one caught with the hand, the other taken from a cleft in the rock. Neither has passed through anyone's kitchen. And the gospel of Luke preserves a saying of Jesus that completes the picture: John came eating no bread and drinking no wine. Bread is the food of all foods that is made by other hands. Someone sows it, someone reaps, someone grinds, someone bakes.
The scholar's proposal is that this is not a prophet's costume but an Essene's predicament. John was of a priestly family, the child of old parents, and the same gospel says he was in the wilderness until the day of his showing to Israel. The historian says the Essenes took in the children of others while they were young enough to be shaped. If John was brought up in the community by the Dead Sea, or formed there as a young man, and then left it, his diet is exactly what the oath would have left him. The proposal goes on to guess at why he left: that he had come to believe the call was meant for all Israel and beyond, where the community kept it for the few, and that the difference could not be contained within the walls. Whether he walked out or was put out, the scholar does not claim to know.
A Correction
In The Voice in the Wilderness we counted the honey against John's having kept the Rule, on the ground that the community's purity would almost certainly have forbidden honey from the wild. We now think that was put too strongly, and we have changed the sentence.
What the Damascus Document forbids is defiling oneself with living creatures, and it names the larvae of bees. It does not name honey, and it may mean only that honey must be strained before it is eaten. The philosopher, moreover, lists the keeping of bees among the occupations of the Essenes. And the same Damascus Document that is so careful about bees gives directions for eating locusts: they are to be put into fire or water while still alive. So both of John's foods were known to the community's own law, and neither was plainly forbidden by it. The honey is not the evidence against his membership that we took it to be. We are grateful to have been made to look again.
The Weighing
That does not make the proposal proved, and the fellowship should weigh it as we weigh everything.
For it: it explains three odd details at once, the hair, the honey, and the absence of bread, by a single cause that the ancient sources attest. It fits the geography and the family. And it fits the quarrel we thought we heard in John's preaching, between the closed pool and the open river.
Against it: every detail has another explanation ready. The dress is Elijah's. The refusal of wine is the vow of the Nazirite, which the gospel of Luke says was laid on John before his birth. Locusts and wild honey are simply what there is to eat in that country if one has no field. A critic of the theory points out that John's fare was harsher than anything the witnesses report of the Essenes, who by all accounts ate bread at every meal; and that is true, though it is the Essene inside the walls who ate the community's bread, and the proposal concerns a man outside them. And no ancient writer, in the gospels or out of them, says that John was ever a member of anything.
So we hold it as a good possibility and no more. It is more than we knew before. It gives a reason, drawn from the sources, why a man formed in the desert community might be found a day's walk north of it, alone, eating from the rock.
Leaving and Keeping
Whether or not it is true of John, the picture has stayed with the fellowship, because we know so many people it is true of.
A great many students come to us having left something: a church, a religious order, a strict family, one of the schools described in the Discernment room. They left for good reasons. And they find, sometimes to their dismay, that the house they left is still in them. They cannot pray the way their neighbors pray. They cannot be easy where others are easy. The oath has outlasted the membership, and for a while they feel like the historian's outcasts, unable to eat at any table and living on grass.
If the proposal is right, John is the patron of such people. He did not go back, and he did not throw the discipline away. He kept the washing, the fasting, the plainness, the wilderness, and the verse of Isaiah, and he left behind the wall. What he had been given for the few, he carried out to the many, and stood in a river where anyone could reach him. The discipline that might have starved him became the thing he had to give.
The student who has left a house and cannot shake its habits might ask, at the Evening Watch, which of them are walls and which are disciplines. The walls can be left where they stand. The disciplines were paid for, sometimes dearly, and they are hers to keep. It may be that someone at the river is waiting for exactly what she learned inside.