Articles

If All Is Appointed

The Essenes believed that everything is appointed, and no one in Israel worked harder at choosing well. A letter to a student who asked why she should rise at all.

A letter of a certain kind comes to the fellowship every year or so, usually from a student who has just read the teaching of The One Law for the second time. It says, in one form or another: you tell me that the Essenes believed God established the whole design of things before they existed, and that nothing can be changed. You also tell me to rise before the sun, to choose the light each morning, and to examine my choices each night. Which is it? If all is appointed, then whether I rise tomorrow is appointed too, and I may as well stay in bed and find out.

It is a fair question, and it is very old. This article is the long answer I have never had room for in a letter.

Three Schools, Three Answers

The historian thought the question so important that he used it to tell the three schools of his people apart. The Sadducees, he says, do away with fate altogether. God neither does nor sees anything evil; good and evil lie before each person to choose, and each makes his own fortune. The Pharisees hold that some things are the work of fate and some are in our own power; fate cooperates in every action, but to do right or wrong rests chiefly with us. And the Essenes declare that fate is mistress of all, and that nothing befalls anyone except by her decree.

Fate is the historian's Greek word for it, as the page on The Three Sects notes. The scrolls have no such goddess. They have a sentence, in the Community Rule: from the God of knowledge comes all that is and shall be. Before they existed he established their whole design, and when they come into being at their appointed times they carry out their work according to his glorious design, and nothing can be changed. The hymns say it more personally. What can I say that is not known beforehand, and what can I utter that has not been told? Everything is engraved before you.

So the historian reported them correctly. Of all the schools of Israel, the people of the scrolls gave the most to God's ordaining and the least to human choosing.

The Puzzle

And here is what makes the student's question so sharp. These same people called themselves the volunteers. It is one of their commonest names for a member: one who freely offers himself. They demanded of a candidate two years of proving and a solemn oath. They examined every member every year and moved him up or down according to his deeds. They fined a man for laughing at the wrong moment. A teacher of the churches who has little love for the Essenes has noticed the same thing, and puts it fairly: they held that everything is ordained, and they did not for a moment suppose that this excused anyone from answering for what he did.

A people who truly believed that nothing they did could make any difference would have been the idlest in the land. The Essenes were the busiest. Whatever the teaching meant to them, it did not mean what the student in bed thinks it means.

How They Held Both

I have read the hymns for many years with this question in mind, and I have noticed where the language of appointing falls. It falls almost entirely in two places.

It falls on the good the singer finds in himself. You have opened my ears. You have set my foot on the rock. I know that righteousness does not belong to a man, nor perfection of way to a son of man; to God Most High belong all the works of righteousness. Whenever the singer has understood something, or stood firm, or been kept from falling, he says it was given, and given before he was born.

And it falls on the whole: the seasons, the courses of the stars, the rise and end of the dominion of darkness. These are fixed, and he rests in their being fixed.

Where it does not fall is on his sins. Those he owns. I am a creature of clay, a foundation of shame, a source of impurity. He does not say, you appointed my transgression, and so it is no fault of mine. He says, I have gone astray, and you have forgiven.

A logician would object that this is uneven. If the good in me is God's doing, so is the evil; and if the evil is mine, so is the good. The objection is sound, and the hymns ignore it. They are not a philosophy of the will. They are the grammar of a certain kind of heart: one that gives thanks for everything good in it as a gift, and takes the blame for everything bad as its own. The fellowship has come to think that this unevenness is not a flaw in their thinking. It is the most accurate account of the inner life that can be given from inside it. Every honest person who has been delivered from something knows that she did not deliver herself, and knows equally that her falls were her own.

A rabbi who taught two generations after the temple fell put the whole matter in a single line, and neither side has improved on it: everything is foreseen, and freedom is given. He did not explain how. Paul wrestles with the same pair through three chapters of his letter to the Romans and ends not with a solution but with a cry of praise at the depth of what he cannot search out.

Three Ways It Goes Wrong

A teaching this strong does harm when it is taken by the wrong handle. I have seen three ways.

The first is the excuse. It was meant to be, said of one's own unkindness or one's own sloth. This is the student in bed. The hymns never use the teaching so, and that is the test: if I am using what is appointed to explain why I did wrong, I have picked it up backward.

The second is despair. A student falls into the same fault for the twentieth time and concludes that she must belong to the other lot, that the darkness has been appointed for her. The teaching of the Children of Light has the answer in its own words: the darkness in you is not evidence that you are of the darkness. The Rule says that every person has a portion in both spirits, and that the children of light themselves go astray. No one is told which lot she is in. She is told to choose the light this morning.

The third is the judgment of others, and it was the desert community's own failing. If the lots are fixed, it is a short step to deciding who is in which, and the scrolls take that step: we are the sons of light, and those outside are the sons of darkness, to be loved and hated accordingly. The gospel of the Way refused the step. It kept the urgency and the choice and would not let anyone draw up the lists. The article Was Jesus an Essene? shows what that refusal looked like in practice.

The Order of the Two

What, then, shall I tell the student in bed?

I tell her that the two truths belong to two different hours, and that nearly all the trouble comes from using one of them at the hour that belongs to the other.

Before the act, there is only choice. At the Morning Watch the fellowship says, today I choose the light, and names one place to choose it. No one standing at the beginning of a day has any business asking what has been appointed for it. She does not know, and she is not meant to. The alarm rings, and the only question is whether she will get up.

After the act, there is only gift. At the Evening Watch, when the day is examined and returned, the student may say of whatever was good in it: this was given. And of the day as a whole, with its failures confessed and its outcomes out of her hands, she may say: it is with God. The teaching of The Soul and Its Journey ends with the practice of giving the day back. That giving back is what the doctrine of appointment is for. It is not a theory about the morning. It is a way of setting the evening down.

So the rule I would offer is this. Choose in the morning as though nothing were appointed. Rest at night as though everything were. The Essenes did both, every day, for two hundred years, and did not find them in conflict, because they never tried to do them at the same time.

And if, tomorrow, the student rises before the sun, she will be free to say at evening that it was given to her to rise. I think she will find that she means it.