Articles

He Will Make the Dead Live

Did the Essenes expect the dead to rise? The historian says one thing, a fragment from the fourth cave says another, and the fragment matches an answer Jesus once sent to a man in prison.

Students often ask whether the Essenes believed in the resurrection of the dead, and they are surprised to find that the answer is disputed. It is one of the places where our witnesses and our scrolls do not quite meet, and where a few lines on a scrap of leather have turned out to matter more than whole pages of the historian.

The fellowship's seventh teaching, The Soul and Its Journey, sets out what the historian says and what the Community Rule and the hymns say, and draws from them the picture of the tent and the traveler. This article goes back over the evidence more slowly, and adds a fragment that the teaching page does not discuss.

Two Reports

The historian is definite. The Essenes hold, he says, that bodies are corruptible and souls immortal; that the soul is drawn down into the body as into a prison; and that at death it is set free and rises rejoicing. He says nothing of the body being raised. He compares their teaching to that of the Greeks, with an island of the blessed beyond the ocean.

But a churchman of Rome in the third century, who retells the historian's whole description of the Essenes almost sentence by sentence, departs from him at just this point. The doctrine of the resurrection, he writes, is strong among them; they confess that the flesh too will rise and be immortal, as the soul is immortal already. Either he changed his source to make the Essenes more agreeable to Christians, or he had a fuller source than we have. No one can say which. But it means that already in the ancient world there were two reports.

The historian's reasons for preferring the Greek version are not hard to guess. As the page on The Three Witnesses explains, he was writing for educated Romans, to whom the immortality of the soul was a respectable opinion held by philosophers, and the raising of corpses was not. He treats the Pharisees the same way, describing their hope in terms a Greek would not have found absurd.

What the Scrolls Say

For a long time the scrolls seemed to side with neither report. The Community Rule promises the children of truth eternal joy in life without end, a crown of glory, and a garment of majesty in unending light. That is plainly a hope beyond death, but it does not say how it comes about. The hymns speak, as the teaching page shows, as though the singer had been raised already: lifted from the pit to an everlasting height, set among the holy ones.

There are hints of more. One hymn praises God for raising the worm of the dead from the dust to an everlasting council. The book of Daniel, which says in so many words that many who sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, was read at Qumran in at least eight copies. The books of Enoch, which they loved, describe the chambers where the spirits of the dead wait for the day of judgment. And a work found in several copies retells Ezekiel's vision of the valley of dry bones, in which bone joins to bone and breath enters the slain, as God's answer to the question of how the faithful will be repaid.

The Fragment

Then, when the fragments of the fourth cave were finally published, there was this. It is part of a single column, from a manuscript copied about a century before the common era. I give the sense of its central lines.

The heavens and the earth will listen to his anointed one. The Lord will seek out the pious and call the righteous by name; over the poor his spirit will hover, and he will renew the faithful with his strength. He will honor the pious on the throne of an everlasting kingdom, setting prisoners free, opening the eyes of the blind, lifting up those who are bowed down. And the Lord will do glorious things that have never been, as he said: for he will heal the wounded, and the dead he will make live; to the poor he will bring good news.

Most of the phrases are from scripture. Setting prisoners free, opening the eyes of the blind, and raising those who are bowed down come from the hundred and forty-sixth psalm. Good news to the poor is from the sixty-first chapter of Isaiah. But neither that psalm nor that chapter says anything about the dead. The writer has added it, quietly, to the list of what God does, and set it just before the good news to the poor.

The Answer Sent to John

Now turn to the gospels. John is in prison. He has heard what Jesus is doing and sends two of his disciples with a question: are you the one who is to come, or shall we look for another? Jesus does not say yes. He says: go and tell John what you have seen and heard. The blind receive their sight, the lame walk, lepers are cleansed, the deaf hear, the dead are raised up, the poor have good news preached to them.

It is a list drawn from Isaiah, as the list in the fragment is drawn from Isaiah and the psalm. And it contains the same addition. The verses of Isaiah from which the list is drawn do not speak of the dead being raised. The fragment adds it; the saying adds it; and both put it in the same place, immediately before the good news to the poor.

I do not think Jesus was quoting the fragment, and I know of no one who can show that he had read it. What the likeness shows is that there was a known way of describing the days of the anointed one: a list of the works of God, built from these verses, in which the raising of the dead had come to stand next to the last. John, formed on the ground the desert community had prepared, as the article The Voice in the Wilderness argues, would have known the list. He asked a question, and he was answered with the signs he had been taught to look for, one by one, in order. The answer left it to him to draw the conclusion.

The Graves

One more piece of evidence is not written at all. The graves beside the settlement are dug in careful rows, and in nearly all of them the body lies on its back along a line from south to north, the head at the southern end. A French scholar of the scrolls, a priest who has argued more fully than anyone that the Essenes expected the resurrection, has pointed out that in the books of Enoch the paradise of righteousness and the throne of God lie to the north. The dead of Qumran, on this view, were laid so that when they rose they would be facing it.

That is a guess, and other reasons for the direction of the graves can be imagined. But it is a fact that the community buried its dead with great care, singly, in order, each under a heap of stones, and not in the family tombs with gathered bones that were the custom of the age. They treated each body as if it would be wanted again.

The Weighing

The question is still open, and I would not have the student think otherwise. The fragment may not be the community's own composition; like much in the caves, it may be a writing from the wider Judaism of the time that they kept and copied. The hymns can be read as speaking of a new life now and not of bodies later. The historian knew living Essenes and we do not.

My own judgment is that the two reports are both partly right, and that the choice between an immortal soul and a risen body is one the community would not have understood. Those are Greek alternatives. The scrolls speak a Hebrew that does not divide a person so neatly. They say that the member has been raised already and stands with the holy ones; that God will renew his creation at the appointed time; and, in at least one place, that he will make the dead live. They did not feel the need to make a system of it. They added it to the list of things God does.

For the One Who Grieves

The fellowship does not define the geography of what lies beyond death, as the teaching page says, and nothing in this article changes that. But the fragment has given some of us a way of praying beside a grave when we did not know what we believed.

It is a list, and one does not have to hold a doctrine in order to read a list. On the anniversary of a death, or at the Evening Watch in a season of mourning, read the hundred and forty-sixth psalm aloud: who executes justice for the oppressed, who gives food to the hungry; the Lord sets the prisoners free, the Lord opens the eyes of the blind, the Lord lifts up those who are bowed down. And then add, as someone by the Dead Sea added two thousand years ago, in the same breath and without argument: and the dead he will make live.

Whoever first wrote that line had no proof. He had a psalm, a list of things he had seen God do, and a grave somewhere that he could not leave out. He put it on the list, and passed the list on. We do the same.