When the historian sets out the schools of his people he counts three, and then, a little grudgingly, a fourth. He gives it no name. He calls it only the fourth philosophy, says that it agreed with the Pharisees in everything else, and adds the one thing that set it apart: an unconquerable love of liberty, and the conviction that God alone is ruler and lord. Its followers, he says, thought little of dying any kind of death, or of seeing their kin and friends die, so long as they need call no man master.
The page on The Three Sects gives this fourth way a paragraph. It deserves a page, because it was the fourth philosophy and not the other three that brought the Roman legions, and because the Essenes cannot be understood without asking where they stood when the legions came.
The Census
In the sixth year of the common era Rome removed Herod's son from the rule of Judea, as the story of Simon the Essene on the Essenes Known by Name page tells, and made the country a province under its own governor. The first act of the new order was a census, so that the land and its people could be taxed directly.
A man from the hills east of the Lake of Galilee, called Judas the Galilean, raised a revolt with a Pharisee named Zadok at his side. Their teaching was simple. To be counted by Caesar was to belong to Caesar. To pay him tribute was to accept a master other than God, and that was slavery. If the people would only refuse, God would fight for them. The rising was put down, and Judas perished. But the historian says the idea did not die with him, and that from it grew every trouble that followed. The sons and grandsons of Judas turn up again and again in the next sixty years, each time at the head of armed men.
The Dagger Men
About the middle of the century a new kind of fighter appeared in Jerusalem. The Romans called them sicarii, from the short curved dagger they carried under their cloaks. Their method was the festival crowd. They would press close to a man in the throng, strike, and then join loudly in the cry of horror, and so were never found. Their first victim was a high priest. Their targets were not Romans but Jews of rank who worked with Rome. Later they took hostages from the great priestly houses and traded them for their own prisoners.
When the war began in the year 66, a descendant of Judas the Galilean led the dagger men up to the rock fortress of Masada above the Dead Sea, took it from its Roman garrison by stealth, and armed his followers from Herod's old stores. They held it until three years or more after Jerusalem had fallen. The historian tells how it ended: a Roman ramp raised against the cliff, a breach in the wall, and nine hundred and sixty men, women, and children dead by their own hands before the soldiers came through.
The Zealots
The name Zealot, which is often used for the whole movement, belongs properly to a party that formed in Jerusalem in the second winter of the war. They were priests of the lower ranks and fighters who had fled into the city from the countryside as the Roman army advanced. They seized the temple and made it their fortress. They overthrew the high-priestly families in blood, and chose a new high priest by casting lots, which fell on a village stonecutter who hardly knew what the office was. The historian was appalled. A student who has read The Lot and the Diviner may see in it something more than a mockery: an attempt, however violent, to take the choice out of the hands that had bought and sold it.
Then the factions turned on one another. While the Roman general drew his lines around the walls, three parties of revolutionaries fought for the temple courts and burned one another's grain. The city that fell in the summer of the year 70 had been half destroyed from within.
Zeal and the Way
The gospels move in this same landscape. One of the twelve is called Simon the Zealot. When Jesus is asked in the temple whether it is lawful to pay tribute to Caesar, the question is the question of Judas the Galilean, and it is asked to trap him: yes would cost him the people, and no would cost him his life. His answer, to give Caesar what bears Caesar's image and God what bears God's, belongs to neither party. On the night of his arrest he tells a disciple to put up his sword. And he dies on a Roman cross between two men for whom the gospels use the same word the historian uses for the armed bands of the hills.
Where the Essenes Stood
The evidence points two ways, and the fellowship will not tidy it.
On one side, the witnesses describe a people of peace. The philosopher says that no maker of weapons could be found among them. The historian says they carried arms on a journey only for fear of robbers, that they were just dealers and restrainers of anger, and that their oath bound them to harm no one, whether of their own will or under orders. The closing hymn of the Community Rule has the member say: I will not repay anyone with evil; with good will I pursue each one, for judgment of all the living is with God.
On the other side stands the War Scroll, which plans a real war in real detail, with the ages of the soldiers and the length of the spears. The same hymn that renounces revenge goes on to say that the singer will not turn back his anger from the men of injustice until the day of vengeance. The historian names John the Essene as a general of the revolt. He says that the war with Rome tested the Essenes in every way, and describes them tortured by the legions. The settlement at Qumran was burned by the Roman army in the year 68. And when the fortress of Masada was excavated, fragments of scrolls were found there, among them a copy of the songs for the Sabbath sacrifice that are otherwise known only from the caves of Qumran. Someone who owned such a book died on the rock with the dagger men, or left it there.
Put together, the pieces suggest a people who did not seek the war and could not stay out of it. The revolutionaries believed that the kingdom of God must be seized, and that God would help those who struck first. The community of the scrolls believed that the war of the last days would begin at the time God had appointed and not an hour before, and until then the sword stayed in its sheath and the anger was stored. When the legions came down the Jordan valley, it must have seemed to some of them that the hour had struck. Several scholars think the community, or part of it, hid its books in the caves and went out to meet what it took to be the last battle. If so, they were mistaken about the hour, and they paid for it with everything they had.
What the Fellowship Takes
The fellowship draws a hard lesson from the fourth philosophy and a harder one from the Essenes.
The lesson of the fourth philosophy is that a true thing held without discernment can destroy what it loves. That God alone is lord is the first sentence of the faith of Israel. Judas the Galilean believed it with his whole heart, and the end of his teaching was a burned temple and a people scattered for nineteen centuries. The elders of the Egyptian desert, whom the Discernment room quotes, would have recognized the case: zeal without eyes.
The lesson of the Essenes is nearer home. A community may renounce violence for itself and still keep a store of anger for a later day. The Rule did both in one hymn. The teaching of the Sanctity of Life, as its page says, comes to the fellowship from the wider stream of the tradition and from the gospel of the Way, where the enemy is to be loved now and not merely spared until the day of vengeance. We do not claim that the ancient Essenes had reached it. We think they were on the road to it, and that the war overtook them on the road.
For the student, the practice is the examination at the Evening Watch, with one question added in angry seasons: what am I storing? An anger put away for later is not peace. It is a scroll hidden in a cave, and sooner or later someone finds it.