Discernment

Under the Essene Name

Many groups today take the Essene name, and their critics say they are to be avoided. What the critics get right, and eight questions to ask of any such group, this one included.

"By their fruits you shall know them."

After the gospel of Matthew

A student who searches for the Essenes today will find the ancient ones on the first page of results and the modern ones on every page after. There are Essene churches and Essene orders, Essene schools of healing, Essene diets, Essene retreats, and teachers who say they hold the true line of the desert. The fellowship has said on its Questions and Answers page that it is connected with none of them and speaks of them without scorn. A student deserves more than that sentence. She deserves a way to judge for herself, and she deserves to see us submit to the same judgment.

What the Critics Say

The sharpest critics of the modern Essene groups are teachers of the evangelical churches, and they do not soften their words. One widely read handbook of answers to questions about the Bible, after a fair summary of who the ancient Essenes were, turns to the present. The Essenes as a sect of Judaism no longer exist, it says, but there are groups on the fringe that take their name. It lists what it finds in them: a holy book other than the Bible; a heavy reliance on mysticism and private revelation; the belief that they and they alone possess the truth; and the denial of doctrines its authors hold essential. Its conclusion is one sentence long. Such groups are to be avoided.

A second critic, a teacher who presents the history of the Bible to general listeners, is gentler and in some ways goes deeper. Modern movements that claim Essene identity, this teacher says, mix a few historical elements with esoteric and mystical ideas that have nothing to do with the Jewish world the Essenes lived in. Their claims about Essene healing rites, hidden powers, and secret gospels have no support in the ancient evidence. No modern group reliably preserves what the ancient sect believed or did. And the same teacher adds a sentence the fellowship would gladly sign: the truth about the Essenes is found in careful study of the sources, not in romantic projection.

Where the Critics Are Right

On the history, they are right, and the fellowship says so without reserve. No living group descends from the people of the scrolls. There is no line of teachers from Qumran to anyone's meeting room. The article How a Tradition Grows shows where the modern Essene tradition was actually built, and the page on The Modern Essene Gospels shows where its books came from. Anyone who claims otherwise is asking to be believed without evidence.

They are right, too, that the ancient Essenes were Jews through and through, and that a teaching which lifts them out of the Law, the Sabbath, the covenant, and the quarrels of the second temple has made them into someone else.

And they are right about the mark of exclusive truth, though here there is a twist they do not remark on. The belief that we alone hold the truth is, as it happens, the one thing a modern group could claim to have inherited faithfully. The desert community believed exactly that. It called itself the sons of light and everyone else the sons of darkness, and it cursed those who left. If there is one feature of the ancient Essenes that no one should wish to revive, it is this, and the gospel of the Way was in large part an answer to it. A group that has borrowed the white robes and left the curses behind has chosen well. A group that has kept the curses has kept the worst of the inheritance.

Where We Differ

We differ from the handbook on two of its marks. It counts it against a group that it reads books beyond the Bible. The ancient Essenes read Enoch and Jubilees beside the Law, as the page on The Scriptures of the Caves shows, and the letter of Jude in the New Testament quotes Enoch by name. Reading widely is not the fault. The fault is passing off a new book as an old one, or setting any book above the reader's conscience.

It also counts mysticism against them. The fellowship has answered that elsewhere, in the article The Company He Kept. A hunger for the direct knowledge of God is not a mark of error. The scriptures are full of it. The mark of error is the refusal to test what one has been given, and that is found as often among the plain as among the mystical.

And we differ in the yardstick. The handbook measures by its creed, and a group fails if it does not hold it. We do not think less of it for that; a creed is what it was written to defend. But the fellowship asks no one to hold a creed, and so we cannot use one as a measure. We need tests that a student of any belief or none can apply, and that a group cannot pass merely by saying the right words.

Eight Questions

These are the questions the fellowship would ask of any group that takes the Essene name, or any other.

  • Does it claim a lineage? If it says its teaching has come down from the desert in an unbroken line, ask to see the line. There is none to show.
  • Does it have a book that only it has seen? The four questions on the Modern Essene Gospels page apply. A scripture that cannot be examined by outsiders is a claim, not a text.
  • Does it say that it alone has the truth? Listen to how it speaks of those outside it, and above all of those who have left it.
  • Does the real teaching cost money, or lie behind a door? Paying for a book or a meal is ordinary. Paying, or being promoted, in order to be told what the others are not told is the pattern described on the page The Secret Chiefs.
  • Does it tell you what it does not know? A teacher who is never uncertain about the first century has not studied it.
  • Can you leave? Ask what happens to those who go. If the answer involves fear, shunning, or a debt, you have your answer.
  • Does it draw you toward the people in your life, or away from them? A way that costs a student her family, her friends outside the group, or her doctor has taken something it had no right to.
  • Who is better off because it exists, besides its members? The historian praised the Essenes for their care of the sick and the stranger. The page on Service and Kindness says that without the outward turn the inward practices curdle.

None of these is about doctrine. A group might teach things the fellowship thinks mistaken and pass every one of them, and we would call it a good neighbor. A group might teach nothing we could fault and fail four, and we would tell a student to walk away.

The Questions Turned on Us

It would be poor discernment to hand a student a set of tests and not stand under them.

We claim no lineage, and say so on the About page. We have no hidden book; our own readings, the Lections, are marked as ours wherever they appear. But some of our teachings came to us through a modern book that made a false claim about its origin, and although we have marked that too, a critic could fairly say we are standing on the same ground as the groups we are describing. The critic would be right. We live on the top layer of the tell with everyone else.

We do not say that we alone have the truth, and we think we could not say it with a straight face. Nothing here costs money and nothing is kept back. We try to say what we do not know, and a student may count the number of times the words we do not know appear on these pages. No one can leave the fellowship, because there is nothing to join.

The last two questions are the ones on which we are least sure of ourselves. A small company that meets to read and pray can become a world of its own, pleasant to its members and of no use to anyone else, and a website can be a way of feeling that one has served without the trouble of serving. We do not think this has happened. We are not the ones who would notice first. If a student sees it in us, she should say so, and then she should apply her finding to us as she would to anyone.

What the Desert Would Say

It is worth asking, finally, what the people of the scrolls would have made of all of us who use their name: the churches, the orders, the schools, and this fellowship with its twenty minutes at dawn. They would have examined each of us before the overseer, set us to a year of probation outside the common meal and a second year outside the common drink, and then, we strongly suspect, sent the whole company home. We keep the wrong calendar. We eat with anyone. We have never once been fined for laughing.

That thought is a good companion. No one alive is an Essene. What remains is a library, three outside witnesses, a ruin, and a set of practices that anyone may try. Whoever uses the name today has borrowed it, the fellowship included, and the honest thing to do with something borrowed is to say so and to take care of it. The critic was right that the truth about the Essenes is in the sources. We would add only that what a person does at dawn, after she has read them, is hers.