History

The Qumran Question

Were the people of the scrolls the Essenes of the ancient writers? The case for, the case against, and how the fellowship holds the question.

"They have no one city, but many of them settle in every town."

After the ancient historian

This whole site rests on an identification, and a student has a right to know how firm it is. The ancient witnesses describe a people they call Essenes. The caves by the Dead Sea gave up the library of a community that calls itself the Unity, the sons of light, the men of the covenant, and never once Essene. A ruin stands on the terrace beside the caves. Most scholars hold that these three belong together: that the ruin housed the community, that the community owned the library, and that the community was Essene. Some do not, and they are not fools.

The fellowship has said on its Questions and Answers page that most scholars accept the connection. This page shows the working.

The Case For

It begins with a place. The naturalist, as the page on The Three Witnesses tells, puts the Essenes on the west side of the Dead Sea with the town of Engedi below them. Qumran is on the west side of the Dead Sea, north of Engedi, and no other ruin on that shore fits his words half so well.

Then there is the life. The historian describes a people who hand their property to a common fund, who are admitted by stages over three years, who bathe before a common meal at which a priest blesses the food, who are ranked, who are expelled for grave faults, who study the ancient writings, and who believe that all things are in the hand of God. The Community Rule legislates for a people who do every one of these things. The agreement reaches into matters too small to be coincidence. The historian says the Essenes are careful not to spit into the midst of the company. The Rule sets a penalty of thirty days for the man who spits into the midst of the assembly.

Then the ground. The ruin has stepped pools far beyond the needs of any farm, a hall with a pantry of a thousand dishes, and inkwells. The graves beside it are laid in ordered rows, and those opened in the main part held almost only men. The tall jars that held the scrolls of the first cave are of a kind found in the ruin and hardly anywhere else. Several of the caves can be reached only by walking through the settlement. And the dates agree. The coins found in the ruin, more than twelve hundred of them, run from the Hasmonean kings to the years of the war with Rome, and the scrolls were copied across the same span.

The Case Against

The objections are of three kinds.

The first is the name. Not one scroll uses the word Essene, in any language. The identification is an inference from likeness, and likeness is not identity.

The second is the differences. The historian says the Essenes took three years to admit a member; the Rule describes two, after a first examination. He says they avoided oaths; the Damascus Document regulates them. The witnesses describe a people of peace who made no weapons; the caves held the War Scroll. The philosopher and the naturalist say they had no women; the Damascus Document legislates for wives and children, and some of the graves at the edges of the cemetery are those of women and children, though several of these may be Bedouin burials of recent centuries. And the Damascus Document speaks of members who earn wages and give two days' pay each month to the common fund, which is not the single purse the witnesses admired.

The third is the ruin itself. Nothing found in it says what it was. One scholar argued for years that it was a fortress, and that the scrolls were not the library of any one sect but the libraries of Jerusalem, carried down to the desert for safety as the Romans closed in. On that view the variety of the scrolls is just what one would expect, and the Essenes have nothing to do with them. Others have read the ruin as a wealthy farm, or as a roadside station on the salt and balsam trade. Two archaeologists who dug there for ten seasons concluded that it was a pottery works, and that the famous pools were for settling clay.

And there are proposals that keep the community but change its name. Because the letter on points of the Law described on the Before the Desert page takes positions that later rabbis ascribe to the Sadducees, some hold that the founders were priests of that stamp who broke away, and not Essenes at all. Others hold that the Essenes were a broad old movement, and that the people of Qumran were a small party who had split from it to follow the Teacher.

Answers, and What Remains

Most of the differences shrink when looked at closely. The historian's three years and the Rule's two years and a first examination are the same process counted differently. He himself says that the Essenes, who avoid oaths, swear tremendous ones on entering. The wives and wages of the Damascus Document belong to the order of the towns, which the historian also describes, as the article The Two Branches explains. And the page on The Fourth Philosophy has shown that the people of peace and the people of the War Scroll may well have been the same people in different years.

The theory of the Jerusalem libraries has to explain why a collection gathered from all over a divided city should contain so many books of one party and none that plainly speak for its opponents: no book praising the Hasmonean priests, no Pharisee ruling given with approval. It has to explain the jars, and the caves that open only through the settlement. Most scholars have not been persuaded. The farm, the station, and the pottery works each explain some of the stones and none of the scrolls.

But the objections have done real good, because the older picture was too simple. For a generation after the finding, students were taught that Qumran was the Essene headquarters, a kind of monastery where a few hundred celibate men wrote all the scrolls. Hardly anyone holds that now. Many of the scrolls were plainly brought from elsewhere; they are in hundreds of different hands. The Rule itself speaks of every place where there are ten men of the council of the community, which is the language of an association with many small branches and not of a single house. A writer of our own day has put it well: the settlement by the Dead Sea was one expression of the movement, not the whole of it, and perhaps not even its center. That is very nearly what the historian said nineteen centuries ago, when he wrote that they had no one city, but settled in every town.

How the Fellowship Holds It

We hold the identification as the best explanation of the evidence, and we hold it as an explanation and not as a creed. The cautious statement, which a careful Catholic writer of our own day has put in nearly these words, is that the community of the scrolls practiced a form of Jewish life consistent with everything the ancient writers tell us of the Essenes, and was very probably Essene or close kin to the Essenes; that the Essenes were more various in place and practice than the old picture allowed; and that the matter is probable and not proved.

This affects how the pages of this site are written. We try to say the desert community when we mean the people of the scrolls, and the Essenes when we mean the people the witnesses describe, and to let the two names lie side by side as the caves and the ruin do. Where we join them, as we often do, we are following the majority of those who have spent their lives on the question, and the student now knows on what grounds.

And we take a lesson for ourselves. The fellowship has asked itself what would become of our practice if it were shown tomorrow that the people of the scrolls were not Essenes after all. The answer we have come to is that the Morning Watch would be kept the next day as it was kept the day before. The historian's Essenes would still have prayed toward the dawn. The Community Rule would still say what it says about the two spirits and the study of the night. We would have two teachers where we had thought there was one, and we would need to correct a good many sentences. A practice that can survive the correction of its history is standing on the right foundation. A practice that cannot was standing on a story, and the page How a Tradition Grows has said what we think of that.