The page The Tree and Its Branches draws a map of the modern mystery schools: six old roots, a translation in Florence, and the orders that grew from it. A student who has studied the map sometimes writes to say that she has found something that seems to stand above it. It is not a lodge or an order. It is a library, usually the work of a single devoted writer, and it promises to gather every branch of the tree into one path: the temple of Solomon and the Grail, the alchemists' stone and the rose and cross, Enoch and Hermes and the knights and the Christ, all told as chapters of a single story of the soul's exile and return.
Such works are often beautiful, and some of them are honest about what they are. This page is for the student who has found one and wonders how to hold it.
The Shape of a Synthesis
They tend to share a shape. At the center is one great story. A prince has forgotten that he is a prince. He wakes in a far country, remembers his father's house, sets out through trials, and comes home a king. Around the story the traditions are arranged as its chapters: the making of the world, the fall into time and matter, the ancient memory carried by the first peoples, the covenant handed from patriarch to patriarch, the coming of the Christ, the knowledge of the gnostics, the quest of the knights, the art of the alchemists, the initiations of the lodges, and at the end a restored kingdom and an unveiling.
Often there are emblems that serve as doors into the whole: a temple, a cup, a stone, a rose on a cross, a crown. And there is nearly always a line of transmission, a succession of names from Adam and Seth and Enoch through Noah, Abraham, Moses, David, and Solomon, and on through the centuries to the writer's own desk. In such a line the Essenes usually have a place, somewhere between the prophets and the gospel. The old name for the line is the golden chain.
Where the Chain Comes From
The phrase has a history, and the history is worth knowing, because it shows that the chain is itself one of the links.
It begins as a boast. In the oldest of the Greek epics the chief of the gods tells the others that if they hung a golden chain from heaven and all pulled on it together, they could not drag him down, while he could haul up the lot of them with the earth and sea besides. The Platonists of the late ancient world, whom the Tree page counts as the second root, read the passage as a picture of the way all things hang from the One, level below level. Their last schools then applied it to themselves: the succession of their teachers from Plato onward was the golden chain, each master handing the truth to the next.
When the Hermetic books were put into Latin in Florence in 1463, the scholar who translated them took a further step. He supposed that Hermes had lived about the time of Moses, and he drew up a line of ancient theologians, six in number, running from Hermes down to Plato, who had all taught one wisdom. He was mistaken about the date by more than a thousand years, as a later scholar showed from the style of the Greek. But the idea outlived the correction. In the eighteenth century the chain turns up as the title of an alchemical book much loved in the Rosicrucian lodges, and from there it passes into nearly every school on the map.
So the golden chain is not a discovery about the traditions. It is a way of arranging them that was invented by one of them, taken up by a translator who had his dates wrong, and handed on. A synthesis that presents the chain as the frame of history has taken one room of the house and called it the foundation.
The Prince and the Pearl
The story of the exiled prince is another matter. It is old, and it is one of the loveliest things the ancient world has left us.
It is found in a book of the early Syrian church that tells of the travels of the apostle Thomas, where it is put into the apostle's mouth as a song. A king's son is sent from his home in the East down into Egypt to bring back a pearl that lies in the sea, guarded by a serpent. He puts on the clothing of the Egyptians so as not to be known, eats their food, and forgets that he is a king's son, and forgets the pearl, and sinks into a deep sleep. His parents write him a letter. It flies to him in the form of an eagle and becomes speech: rise up from your sleep; remember that you are a son of kings; see whom you have served in slavery; remember the pearl. He wakes, charms the serpent, takes the pearl, strips off the foreign clothes, and goes home, where the robe he left behind comes out to meet him, and he sees in it his own true self.
The modern syntheses are, at their best, retellings of this song. A student should know that she can read the song itself, that it is some eighteen hundred years old, and that it needs no chain of transmission to reach her. It reached its first hearers as the letter reached the prince, directly, and it has been doing so ever since. The page on The Nag Hammadi Library describes the sayings gospel that bears the same apostle's name.
Three Questions
The fellowship's two questions for this room are who is answering, and can you show me the page. For a synthesis we would put the second question in three forms.
- Is it offered as a work, or as a discovery? There is all the difference in the world between a writer who says, I have gathered these traditions into one story because I find it true and beautiful, and a writer who says, this is the hidden history of the world. The first is doing what poets and theologians have always done. Some modern syntheses say plainly that they are a conscious gathering, one writer's work, a perspective. That candor deserves respect, and the fellowship gives it. The second claim needs evidence that no one has.
- Where exactly are the joins? Each tradition in the story is real and has its own texts. The joins between them are the writer's. Enoch is in Genesis and in the caves. The Grail is in French romances of the twelfth century. The stone is in the alchemists. That the three belong to one transmission is not in any of those sources; it is in the synthesis. A student can honor the parts and still ask of every join: who first drew this line, and when?
- Can the story lose? The article Was Jesus an Essene? observes that an explanation which turns every fact into support is not evidence but a frame. A great story that has a place prepared for every tradition, every symbol, and every objection is a frame of that kind. This does not make it false. It means that its fitting everything tells you about the skill of the maker and nothing about the world.
Outer and Inner Libraries
Many such works are arranged in tiers. There is an outer library that anyone may read, and an inner one for members or subscribers, with private teaching beyond that. The fellowship wants to be fair here. A writer must eat, books cost money, and there is no sin in being paid for one's work. Some who arrange their work this way give away the greater part of it.
What the student should watch is not the price but the claim that goes with it. If the inner library holds more of the same, offered to those who wish to support the writer, that is a bookshop, and an honest one. If the inner library is said to hold what the outer cannot, the thing itself, the key without which the rest does not open, then the student has met the oldest pattern on the map. The page The Secret Chiefs tells where it leads. The fellowship has said why it sells nothing and keeps nothing back, and we do not hold others to our rule. We say only what we have found: the Way was a practice done in the open at dawn, and nothing that mattered in it was ever behind a door.
It is fair to add that the desert community would not have agreed with us. They kept their teaching from outsiders and admitted a man by degrees, as the page The Shape of the House shows. On this point the fellowship follows the teacher of the Way, who said that what is whispered in the inner room is to be proclaimed on the housetops.
What a Synthesis Gives
None of this is said to take a good thing from anyone. The hunger for one story is not foolish. A person who has read the scrolls and the gospels and the Kabbalists and the alchemists, and has found something true in each, naturally asks whether the true things are one thing. The syntheses answer yes, and give her a shape to hold it in. The fellowship does something of the kind itself. Our eight teachings draw from the scrolls, the witnesses, the gospels, and a modern book, and we have arranged them in an order of our own. We have only tried to mark each piece with where it came from, so that the student can see the joins.
That is all we ask of any synthesis: that the joins show. A mosaic is not a lie because it is made of pieces. It becomes one only when someone says it is a single stone.
Where the Fellowship Stands
We stand where the Tree page says we stand, on the fifth root, with the Torah, the books of Enoch, and the gospels of the Way, and we read the rest as neighbors. We do not teach a golden chain. We think the truth about how the Way has come down is at once humbler and more encouraging: it has been lost and found, again and again, by people with no link to one another at all. The monks of Egypt went into the desert without having read a line of the Community Rule. The scrolls lay in jars for nineteen centuries with no one to hand them on. The song of the pearl says the same thing in its own way. The prince is not woken by a succession of teachers. He is woken by a letter from home, and the letter comes to him where he is.
A student may keep her great story, and we hope it serves her. But when it tells her that the truth has reached her down a chain, she might remember the letter, and that it was addressed to her by name.